120346
Current Talk '05 II / Re: Where was the Secret in 1840?
« on: September 10, 2005, 09:22:28 PM »I always thought that it may have been Petofi's spirit haunting Collinwood in the present with his image presented as Quentin via Charles Tate's painting. Thats why the present time family still remembered the haunting of "Quentin" and Beth.
Interesting theory - but I'm not so sure it can fly. Unless Beth was deliberately trying to mislead Julia in Ep #836 (and that certainly doesn't appear to be the way things play out), the spirit that haunted Collinwood was Quentin because when Beth tells Julia why Quentin is so interested in David, she explains it's because Quentin's spirit loves David because he reminds him of Jamison. It seems unlikely Petofi would have had any such interest in either Jamison or David.