177
« on: October 27, 2002, 05:20:18 AM »
Do I take it that "12 Monkeys" is not one of your favorites either? Love that movie. There is no way that anyone could ever smooth out all the time wrinkles in the DS fabric, but let me get a few.
Barney reacted vehemently to Phyliss Wicke because he recognized her and he was afraid. Seeing someone you knew almost 200 years ago COULD do that to you! Didn't further his purpose because she could have been told he was a descendant of the original Barney. It was just the same reaction that Vicky had when she thought she recognized someone. Only in her case it was over, and over, and....
I personally don't think time travel has to adhere to strict rules. Vicky could have been returned to five minutes after she left or a week. Time being relative, just because she was gone __ # of weeks, doesn't mean that she would have to be returned __# of weeks later. Same with Phyliss, she could have been returned at time she left, or later as she was. If there are definate rules about this, I do so hope someone will set me straight. I would HATE to be poorly mannered in such matters. Given Einstein's theory of time moving differently for the guy on the rocket ship and him coming back a few years older to an ancient wife, I don't think this is all as ludicrous as it sounds. Or as it really is, I don't know.
For the change in story line, I think the writers used a little diversion tactic to get out of a sticky wicket. There was ONE reference to Carolyn no longer wanting to kill Julia and then no reference was ever made to Carolyn knowing Barney's secret again. Live and let non-live, I guess was her motto. OK, for that part of your questioning, the answer is they cheated. Though for Vicky, while she did RETURN to the same moment or shortly thereafter, she herself had been gone long enough to forget Burke and fall in love with someone else.
I would think that Janet Findley IS alive and never was called to Collinwood. My guess is that Ezra wasn't long for this world, either way. Later, when Quentin eventually shows up in Collinwood, noone gasps and runs away in mortal fear. So I think his ghost had ceased to be.
As for Eagle Hill Cemetary, it must be right next to Wyndcliffe! Either hours away or just a short walk, have your pick. I don't think the time travel created THAT inconstancy.