I think Natalie was lying to Josette. After her seeing Barnabas she would have used any ploy to get Josette out of Collinwood. Josette does not fear enough for her own life so she thought she would convince her that Natalie herself needed protecting. Seeing Barnabas scared the pants off her.
What was with that beauty mark x thing? It reelly bugged me. It also reminded me of a story. Oh no, not again, My friend and I were at a bar, when I was a SYT and we were talking to this guy. My friend told him he had something on his face and went to wipe it away, only it was a mole. hehe. The next time we saw him he had had it removed.
Birdie