Patti,
With respect to costume on DS, one odd thing about the original 1795 storyline stands out: many of the fashions seemed to be a few years ahead of their time!
I have always been fascinated by the history of fashion and know that for women, 1795 was a very transitional period from the tight-laced gowns we think of as typical of the 18th century and the high-waisted, flowing gowns of the Regency era. This is why I am always surprised to see so many of the younger actresses already wearing Regency period gowns. Considering the fact that Collinwood is in Maine and no where near fashion capitals such as Paris and London, these ladies show a sense of fashion that is a bit too "au courant" to be believed!
However, Naomi's 18th century frock is entirely believable on a mature woman of that era as are the gowns and curly hairstyle (fashionable in the 1780s and early 90s) worn by the Countess Du Pres. But - where have all the wigs gone? I would expect at least Joshua to be either earing a wig or to have a little ponytail. Older men often wore their wigs well into the 19th century. Or maybe the Collins family were too Puritanical to put up with such fripperies?
My vote for most accurately costumed DS storyline goes to the 1840 and 1841 ones. For a daytime soap, they really do an excellent job here, especially with the male fashions and hair.
Looks like you touched upon a favorite subject of mine, Patti!