Jeff Kicks Barney's butt!!

My vote goes to Barnabas as well! 

Although it annoyed me when Barnabas gave Jeff orders, as if Jeff had to take them!

Still, Barnabas would have won a fight with him, even without his trusty cane.

Barn went out on many ships and spent time down at the docks, he would have had to learn how to fight dirty. Back in colonial days you had to take care of yourself. No one else did it for you.

Would Joshua have learned to how fight dirty, too?

In a way I'm glad Barnabas hardly ever resorted to fisticuffs, because the fight scenes on the show were usually hysterical in their realism, lots of shoving, kicking and falling into the furniture.