Vlad,
With regards to Gerard, he did befriend Quentin and the Collins family in the beginning. Correct?
Under rather suspect circumstances, yes. Â It appeared from the beginning that he had his eye on Samantha the moment he arrived at Collinwood. Â And the circumstances surrounding the supposed deaths at sea of Quentin and his son (sorry, I can't remember all these names the way others on this board do!) were also suspect.
As I said, the best that was said about him was that he was a 'hustler," (I know that isn't the term, but I can't think of it offhand) -- and that was by a good friend and associate (whose name I can't remember name offhand either -- the Nancy Barrett character).
The fact that he was involved in illegal shipping activities -- pirating -- under a different name (Captain someone) tells you something about his character.
However, I do agree with you about the TLATKLS's Rachel Drummond. The criticism of the character may be due to a lack of understanding on the part of the individual(s).
Yes, Rachel Drummond was a classically Victorian character, basically an example of the Victorian ideal woman -- chaste, pure, innocent, naive. Â KLS's performance was exactly on target.
Luciaphil asked:
I'm curious, Vlad. Â Could you elaborate on why you think she was a successful character?
I'm one of the critics--I always thought she was really very thinly drawn on the part of the writers. Â
In the context of my comments, I meant that this was one character who remained true to type -- i.e., Rachel Drummond did not have a ridiculous turnaround as a Handmaiden of Count Petofi.
I also said (or meant) that I thought this was one of KLS's best performances, aside from Maggie. Much better than her Josette du Pres -- she had much more of a period feel for this character, e.g. her posture and manner; and IMO her acting presented the character perfectly, without some of the infelicities that cropped up in her later performance as Lady Hampshire.
I grant that Rachel Drummond may not be as complex a character as the other two (i.e., Josette and Kitty), so maybe the simplicity of the character ("innocence") was easier for her to play, I don't know. Â But I found her more believable in the role and well-suited to the period.
-Vlad