there are actors who do not ad-lib well if at all. Early and live television is not a medium for those actors who can't ad lib or learn lines quickly. You can be a brilliant actor but suck as an ad libber. If you're experience in television is limited and you wind up being the lead actor on a daily show, I cannot even imagine what that must be like.
He went on to say that more than once he found he had to wear a bathing suit for underwear 'cause he was out of clean underwear, LOL! Mind you, this was in one of the teen rags that are famous for BS articles, so who knows if that was really true.
I think that is why John wanted to have someone come in. Being in so many episodes and doing promotions. John might have just been burned out. The whole show was dependant on him and no other. Lori
Not to belittle Frid, 'cause I *do* think the guy's got talent, but he himself admits to being a 'slow-study' and frankly, he never seemed to be the kind of actor who could 'think on his feet' and recover from a flub like say, Louie Edmonds can. I can't think of a single time where he just winged it and ad-libbed while staying in character. Instead, he'd nervously wring his hands, search for the teleprompter and stutter. Not really a flaw, just some actors can do it and some can't. Frid seems to be the type that can't. Just my 2 pesos...
I have to disagree. Frid was a phenomenal actor, and you've given him some credit for that. However, he was a classically-trained stage actor, and this was a new genre for him. Soap actors will tell you that they virtually have to do a play a day, a pretty daunting challenge for any actor.
The "ad-libbing" comments are interesting. I'm not sure if the ability to ad-lib has all that much to do with acting talent. Obviously, as a soap actor, it's very helpful. I've read that Tony Geary from General Hospital ad-libs all over the place. However, I was also reading how Art Carney, the great TV and movie actor from "The Honeymooners" could not ad-lib and hated that when he was on stage for the original "Odd Couple" Walter Matthau (who played Oscar to Carney's Felix) tended to ad-lib which that would really throw him off balance with his own acting.
Apparently, it was this reason he wasn't too keen on playing with Matthau in the movie version. Jack Lemmon got that project. I totally respect and admire Art Carney's talent, he's the best. So, can't really say that ad-libbing is a sign of credible acting ability. It's just a quirk some people can do and some can't.
Ad libbing is a skill and there are plenty of excellent actors who are not good at it. It has nothing to do with talent.Carney was a brilliant ad libber but was not in top form in "The Odd Couple" partly because of his health. Though its public knowlege in several Carney biographies, he had a very difficult time with the play, and the constant tension didn't help his state of mind any. The play was being re-written or acts and large chunks of dialogue would change from day to day as the play toured. But Carney's health problems really crippled him during that run.
can't really say that ad-libbing is a sign of credible acting ability. It's just a quirk some people can do and some can't.
Really!! I think I must have read the same info. My understanding was that Carney liked to play roles by the book without ad-libbing and that Matthau was the opposite. Though, by watching the Honeymooners there appears to be lots of ad-libbing but I doubt there was. I could be wrong though, I'll have to look this up. I also knew Carney had drinking problems etc. but not sure what that has to do with ad-libbing pro or con.
Stokes/Petofi-- opposite equivalents? Both have that irony, that running inner commentary that they can't help voicing, always separate from the world, observing from the outside at a distance.