231
« on: August 06, 2005, 09:19:59 AM »
I felt Marley Shelton made a good Victoria. She had a good mix of vulnerability and strength. She also was commanding over David. I felt she was eventually going to make inroads with him. I felt little Alexander Gould was truly strong as very disturbed David.
The portrait of Josette was a replication of Marley Shelton in a 17th Century dress with long tresses. It was a nature background I believe. She had a very pretty smile in the portrait. Very much in the style of the time period, in terms of the sitting.
I thought Martin Donovan as Roger Collins and Michael D. Roberts as Sheriff Patterson were the best of the lot.
It appeared to me that Blair Brown and Kelly Hu needed to be re-cast. Or, re-directed. Or, both. There were many points where the direction lacked er Direction. Granted it was rough cut and not polished. You could see the visual click track at the bottom of the screen. But, you can tell if the shots are there and they add to or detract from the horror/suspense or not. The director (PJ Hogan) absolutely needed recasting. Possibly a flogging. My review and fix suggestions will be part of my Fest report when I'm done with it.
Alec Newman was a bit short but they were short 200 years ago. So, it worked for me. Or, Martin Donovan is a basketball player. Your pick.
Joe was hot as was Willie. At first I had the pre-judgment, based on my meeting him at Dan Curtis' 40th Anniversary last year, that Jason Shaw was going to be weak as an actor. However, he surprised me. Matt Czuchry (Willie), Jessica Chastain (Carolyn), Alexis Thorpe (Kelly Greer), Jenna Dewan (Sophia) were all quite competent in their respective roles.
For the most part, this cast gelled for me. Mark Verheiden (writer) really understands DS. My instinct about him from my meeting with him last year was dead on. It would have worked. DS is all the poorer because this failed.
As a friend of mine who is a record producer and performer always said, when you have a new release the entire catalog sells. This really, truly hurt us that this didn't make it.