I can, MB.
The music is as much a part of Dark Shadows as the characters of Barnabas and Victoria. A Dark Shadows lacking the main theme
s is not really Dark Shadows. I don't expect him to reinterpret Cobert's music for his whole score, though he did it for Psycho. I don't need the incidentals. But, I do expect him to channel Cobert in every way he can when it comes to established musical themes. Unfortunately for Elfman, Dark Shadows isn't a new work. It's a remake - not of a book, but of another piece of "film" - and with a remake of such a work comes certain expectations: that all of the important elements of the original are held together so that it is recognizable as being based on the original. They can be re-arranged or reinterpreted, but they should still be present. The music is not something you can remove from Dark Shadows no matter how hard you try. Like I said, I'm not asking for much, just that he uses established character themes if those characters are involved. I'm more understanding if they aren't. But it is inexcusable to create a completely different score for a work that already has an established repertoire of music, just as there is an established repertoire of characters, just because you want to put your own stamp on something. If you have a burning desire to leave your mark, do it on something which hasn't been done before. Otherwise, respect the original source material by using the important elements. And, imo, there are few elements more important than Cobert's main theme
s.
Take a look at Star Wars. It is originally a film. If you were to remake it, there would be the expectation that you include the main theme, of course. But, the expectation is also inherent that you maintain "The Imperial March" and "The Force" themes. Those themes are as important to the feel of Star Wars as Darth Vader and Han Solo. Just as Cobert's other main themes are essential to Dark Shadows. Trust me, if someone were to write a new piece to take the place of the Imperial March simply because he wanted to leave a mark on the new version, I can guarantee you that there would be blood spilled. I feel that expecting any less of Elfman to maintain and utilize original themes is doing an injustice to the original source material, fans, and Cobert himself.
And, yes, I know Cobert has declined the job, but he did mention royalties.
I'd hope for him that there are a great many royalties to be reaped.
Again, just my very strong opinion on the matter. But, I feel I have a right to have a strong opinion - as should other fans of the original and revival. There are three things which have held Dark Shadows together in all of its various forms and through all of its plot lines: The name Collins, the house called Collinwood, and Bob Cobert's music. Nothing else - not even the presence of the supernatural (just some strong allusions to it).