91
Current Talk '08 I / Judith Collins-Trask: Heartless Harridan or Poor, Misunderstood Soul?
« on: April 25, 2008, 02:28:00 AM »
Hey gang,
Of all of the most disagreeable members of the Collins family (and with PT1970 Quentin Collins and 1840's Gabriel Collins there have been more than just a few of them), I find Judith Collins-Trask, the late-19th century mistress of Collinwood, the most difficult to figure out.
When we first see Judith during the start of the 1897 storyline, Judith almost seems to revel in locking horns with her younger brothers, uppity Edward and Carl "The Comedian" Collins, for control of the family fortune. When perpetual bad-boy Quentin Collins shows up, Judith wastes no love on the youngest and, aguably, most charming Collins sibling either.
Of course, Judith is "slightly" less than thoughtful and generous towards the members of the Collinwood staff as well; Judith treats Collinwood head groundskeeper Dirk Wilkins like the proverbial peon (but, then again, Dirk does eventually even the score with his bumptious boss), and, the shameles way that Judith treats the long-suffering, but, ever-faithful Beth Chavez is way beyond the pale.
In addition, being the inveterate nasty-yenta that she is, Judith tries (unsuccessfully) to convince Collins family matriarch Grandmama Edith Collins to evict Edith's friend/fortuneteller, Magda Racosi and Magda's picaresque husband, Sandor, from the Old House. In short, Judith Collins is an extremely parsimonious and cynical individual, who probably wouldn't give her own loving mother the time of day on Christmas morning.
And, yet, after Edith dies and leaves virtually everything in her will to Judith and in sole charge of Collinwood, what does "Miss Misanthrope of 1897" do? She proceeds to fall in love with the shifty Rev. Gregory Trask, a true Tartuffe, and a man I like to think of as "The Eliot Spitzer of Collinsport, Maine"! I mean, how could someone as suspicious and judgmental as Judith fall for a pious con man like the Rev. Trask? (And Judith marries the oily and sanctimonious creep about a week, maybe, after the "reverend" has his "beloved" wife Minera "offed." Go figure!)
So, is Judith the shrew to end all shrews or is she a poor, misunderstood and, ultimately, lonely soul, looking for love in, most decidely, the wrong place?![Undecided [ghost_undecided]](http://www.dsboards.com/SMF/Smileys/classic/ghost_undecided.gif)
Bob the Bartender
Of all of the most disagreeable members of the Collins family (and with PT1970 Quentin Collins and 1840's Gabriel Collins there have been more than just a few of them), I find Judith Collins-Trask, the late-19th century mistress of Collinwood, the most difficult to figure out.
When we first see Judith during the start of the 1897 storyline, Judith almost seems to revel in locking horns with her younger brothers, uppity Edward and Carl "The Comedian" Collins, for control of the family fortune. When perpetual bad-boy Quentin Collins shows up, Judith wastes no love on the youngest and, aguably, most charming Collins sibling either.
Of course, Judith is "slightly" less than thoughtful and generous towards the members of the Collinwood staff as well; Judith treats Collinwood head groundskeeper Dirk Wilkins like the proverbial peon (but, then again, Dirk does eventually even the score with his bumptious boss), and, the shameles way that Judith treats the long-suffering, but, ever-faithful Beth Chavez is way beyond the pale.
In addition, being the inveterate nasty-yenta that she is, Judith tries (unsuccessfully) to convince Collins family matriarch Grandmama Edith Collins to evict Edith's friend/fortuneteller, Magda Racosi and Magda's picaresque husband, Sandor, from the Old House. In short, Judith Collins is an extremely parsimonious and cynical individual, who probably wouldn't give her own loving mother the time of day on Christmas morning.
And, yet, after Edith dies and leaves virtually everything in her will to Judith and in sole charge of Collinwood, what does "Miss Misanthrope of 1897" do? She proceeds to fall in love with the shifty Rev. Gregory Trask, a true Tartuffe, and a man I like to think of as "The Eliot Spitzer of Collinsport, Maine"! I mean, how could someone as suspicious and judgmental as Judith fall for a pious con man like the Rev. Trask? (And Judith marries the oily and sanctimonious creep about a week, maybe, after the "reverend" has his "beloved" wife Minera "offed." Go figure!)
So, is Judith the shrew to end all shrews or is she a poor, misunderstood and, ultimately, lonely soul, looking for love in, most decidely, the wrong place?
![Undecided [ghost_undecided]](http://www.dsboards.com/SMF/Smileys/classic/ghost_undecided.gif)
Bob the Bartender

![Boxing [boxing]](http://www.dsboards.com/SMF/Smileys/classic/boxing.gif)
![Twack [twak]](http://www.dsboards.com/SMF/Smileys/classic/twak.gif)
![Smacked W/ Trout [a395]](http://www.dsboards.com/SMF/Smileys/classic/a395.gif)
![Help! [help]](http://www.dsboards.com/SMF/Smileys/classic/help.gif)
![Angel #7 [angel7]](http://www.dsboards.com/SMF/Smileys/classic/angel7.gif)
![Menorah [Chanukah8]](http://www.dsboards.com/SMF/Smileys/classic/Chanukah8.gif)

![Cool(Green) [coolg]](http://www.dsboards.com/SMF/Smileys/classic/coolg.gif)
![Wave #1 [wave]](http://www.dsboards.com/SMF/Smileys/classic/wave.gif)
![Shocked Santa [santa_shocked]](http://www.dsboards.com/SMF/Smileys/classic/santa_shocked.gif)