4756
Polls Archive / Re: So you want a remake?
« on: September 12, 2006, 12:33:03 AM »
I feel indifferent at this point to the idea of a remake, although as a rule, I hate remakes. I don't think it breaks down to those who were "original broadcast" fans (we used to use the term Ancient Blood, which I quite like) being anti and those of more recent vintage being pro. The people I know who have been enthusiastic about the remakes come in various generations as to whether they were fans in the Sixties, started watching in 1970s or 1980s syndie, or first saw it on the Sci Fi channel in the 1990s.
I think one's reaction to the intrinsic notion of a remake has to do with a certain attitude towards culture in general. I'm WAY too frazzled right now to articulate this, and in any event, it's not really germane to the topic of this thread. I guess what I'm saying here is that I think you're going to find that people are all over the map in terms of Sixties fans/recent generation fans, and where they come down on remakes.
I still think the WB show's approach of having Barnabas be a very different character from the original portrayal worked much better than the DC 1990s version where they gave him a look and (attempted) feel that seemed patterned on the original. It seems to me that the performances in the original, from the likes of Frid, Hall, Thayer David, et al., were so extremely idiosyncratic that you're dooming yourself to failure if you try to imitate--much better trying to take something from the original CONCEPT and making something aesthetically new from that. Just my two drachmae.
G.
I think one's reaction to the intrinsic notion of a remake has to do with a certain attitude towards culture in general. I'm WAY too frazzled right now to articulate this, and in any event, it's not really germane to the topic of this thread. I guess what I'm saying here is that I think you're going to find that people are all over the map in terms of Sixties fans/recent generation fans, and where they come down on remakes.
I still think the WB show's approach of having Barnabas be a very different character from the original portrayal worked much better than the DC 1990s version where they gave him a look and (attempted) feel that seemed patterned on the original. It seems to me that the performances in the original, from the likes of Frid, Hall, Thayer David, et al., were so extremely idiosyncratic that you're dooming yourself to failure if you try to imitate--much better trying to take something from the original CONCEPT and making something aesthetically new from that. Just my two drachmae.
G.
