4483
« on: May 09, 2007, 03:47:38 PM »
I've read fanfic that cast medical-school Julia and Dave as lovers, but re-watching quite a bit of their storyline last year, I don't feel that it really adds up in how their story was played in Canon. I think Julia may have intimidated Dave a bit just because she was so brilliant. She was also extremely caustic and short-tempered (except for when she put on the Niceness Wig when she was trying to get something out of somebody, such as Liz). I'm talking now about the original Julia characterization.
I do think that Dave's death was a horrible turning-point for Julia... in the ORIGINAL '67 storyline. "You no longer have any friends, Julia," rang hideously true for her. I don't think we need to presume a former romantic attachment between them to explicate the horror she feels at her implication in Dave's death. I think it was a major wake-up call for her... the logical conclusion to it was when she informed the family that everything David had said was TRUE.
Julia's character is written very inconsistently during the weeks leading up to 1795 but I'm usually so dazzled by the brilliance of Grayson's thesping that I suspend disbelief. Her behavior on the two days of Barn's aging, for example, is very contradictory. But then, as some wag of the 18th century once wrote, "la donna e mobile" (really explains nothing but is a very pretty conceit).
cheers, G.