Hmmm! Is that a building?!!
I *think* so. At least it appears to be more like a building than anything around the other two #4s does.
I would think one of the other two, which are closer to the main house, would make more sense. Matthew certainly didn't have to travel too far when he was needed.
Agreed.
Perhaps, supposedly like Collinsport itself, the cottage "changes its physical location intermittantly" as well.
When someone living there wants privacy to cast a spell or indulge in a tryst, the cottage is over near the west coastline - but when they're needed at Collinwood it shifts to one of the other #4 locations.
I suppose only the map maker knows what the thinking was for having 3 different #4s. :-