Thank you, Mysterious Benefactor, for your detailed reviews of each episode! I enjoyed reading your thoughts about these teleplays.
I'm afraid I was less impressed than you were, overall. My biggest problem was feeling like the episodes were drawn-out and padded. At first, I thought this was because I had read all the original stories except "And the Bones Came Together," all of which are fairly short and would require more content to fill an 80-minute slot. I particularly thought that the changes made for "The Deadly Visitor" watered down the original story's impact. O'Brien's "What Was It?" is a classic weird tale of the unexplained; attempting to give "It" a human identity and motive made the phenomena less creepy and threatening. Crawford's story "The Screaming Skull" is one of my favorites, and I was deeply disappointed that in the adaptation, the skull never screams and the story's signature, haunting imagery of a little lead ball rattling around inside the brain pan of the murdered woman is absent. However, my boyfriend, who watched along with me, didn't know the source material and also expressed boredom and frustration over how belabored some of the execution was.
The episode I liked most was "The House and the Brain." As far as I'm concerned, this is a totally original story. Its plot has nothing to do with Bulwer-Lytton's work (better known as "The Haunters and the Haunted"), which is about an investigator trying to lay the malevolent ghost occupying a haunted rental house (its conclusion is similar to Hell House). I'm baffled as to why he was cited as the inspiration. Even though I could make reasonable predictions about the trajectory of the story, I was still fascinated to see how it would turn out. I was also impressed by both Hatfield's and Williard's performances.
In general, I did enjoy the DS-like aesthetic and thought McKinley's period outfits (especially from The Haunting of Rosalind) were gorgeous. It was also fun to see Powell and Gardenia (whom I recognized from "All in the Family" and Little Shop of Horrors) as guest stars.
ProfStokes