The body of Carolyn is gone. She did leave some clues to the disaster. The night of the sun and the moon, the night Rose Cottage burned, the unfinished horoscope, the night I sang my song, the murder and the picnic.
Which are apparently events that lead up to the disaster.
Barnabas wants to call the sheriff for a change. I would worry that they would think I killed her. Julia is reluctant but goes. Barnabas sees Gerard and then he and the sheriff find Carolyn in the playroom. Julia decides to stay at Collinwood alone. It is revealed Carolyn died of heart failure. Julia betrays Barnabas and the Sheriff is ready with the cross when he awakens. Now, why he didn't stake him remains a mystery.