Oh well, other than that, I am glad just to be reading something that is both a continuation of the show, and not a fanfiction (although I have seen the arguments that it IS a fanfiction, however, if this is the case, then the entire works of Anne Rice should be classified as fanfiction.)
One poster, I believe, called it fanfiction, and I suppose it is in the sense that LP did not have any hand in creating the series or its characters. However, it is a professional novel, and this is why I'm so critical of it, just as I would point a finger at Anne Rice (whose characters are completely original, btw, so I don't get your analogy) if she were guilty of making the same writing mistakes. Fans are standing in long lines to purchase this book, and for the money I feel she should have done better. And I
have read better [free] fanfic on the net.
I did offer that
The Salem Branch qualifies as a Mary Sue, though I never explained that comment. LP introduced an original character (Antoinette)-- a stand-in for herself who is overly perfect-- while the flaws of other fictional characters, who are not her creations, are emphasized. The author even admits in Q&As to providing Antoinette with some of her own personal experiences.
I did notice something though. Everywhere and everything causes leaves to move, in every possible way. Cars cause leaves to fly, digging makes leaves fall in holes, and leaves turn colors of gemstones. Is it overkill, I don't think so (so far). I am still hoping I will see the symbolism once I have finished the book.
Ha! Yes, the autumn leaves. We discussed that in the preceding pages of this topic. It does get quite annoying, at least that's my be-leaf.