26281
Current Talk '08 I / Re: Discuss - Ep #0461
« on: January 23, 2008, 07:07:00 AM »
The naivete that 60s writers had about time travel ideas showed here.... or else it was naive mainstream viewers they were writing for, not wanting them to get confused. There was never the slightest need to claim that
Collinwood was somehow frozen in time during the time we saw events from 1795. That makes it sound as if 1795 was somehow happening "concurrently" with 1967, when it wasn't. It was 170 years earlier. The point of view of the viewer shifts back 170 years, along with Victoria Winters, then we experience those events, then DS shifts our point of view (and VW) back forward to 1967, or rather 1968 (a glitch we can't resolve). If months had passed in the "present", then as Lydia said, the rest of the world would start to notice the rich freaks playing at being statues... the paper boy would want to be paid and would look through the window, maybe..... and would come in and pants Roger....
We (as observers) and VW traveled back in time, then traveled forward again to the same point in time in the present (not months later). Collinwood wasn't frozen.... it didn't need to be, to explain this. It's just that viewers accustomed to "sensible", straightforward, linear stories would ask... "But what's going on at Collinwood 1967 while all this is happening in 1795?" Answer: nothing of course. Two eras aren't happening at the same time... it's only DS and its wacky storytelling methods that makes it appear that way, if you're not paying attention.
This was such a strange moment. I was really looking forward to it. Stay tuned for DS to catch up with 1968 fast... Julia goes and gets her hair cut, thankfully, meaning the wig gets burnt...
Collinwood was somehow frozen in time during the time we saw events from 1795. That makes it sound as if 1795 was somehow happening "concurrently" with 1967, when it wasn't. It was 170 years earlier. The point of view of the viewer shifts back 170 years, along with Victoria Winters, then we experience those events, then DS shifts our point of view (and VW) back forward to 1967, or rather 1968 (a glitch we can't resolve). If months had passed in the "present", then as Lydia said, the rest of the world would start to notice the rich freaks playing at being statues... the paper boy would want to be paid and would look through the window, maybe..... and would come in and pants Roger....
We (as observers) and VW traveled back in time, then traveled forward again to the same point in time in the present (not months later). Collinwood wasn't frozen.... it didn't need to be, to explain this. It's just that viewers accustomed to "sensible", straightforward, linear stories would ask... "But what's going on at Collinwood 1967 while all this is happening in 1795?" Answer: nothing of course. Two eras aren't happening at the same time... it's only DS and its wacky storytelling methods that makes it appear that way, if you're not paying attention.
This was such a strange moment. I was really looking forward to it. Stay tuned for DS to catch up with 1968 fast... Julia goes and gets her hair cut, thankfully, meaning the wig gets burnt...