25846
Current Talk '08 I / Re: Another thing to think about....
« on: March 21, 2008, 07:22:07 PM »I, myself, have always wondered about the conundrom that is B, J, and E returning to 1971 and having Liz act like they were there all along. The only explanation for it is that they must've returned to an alternate timeline, and therefore the three of them WERE there the entire time, having never gone back in time to right everything in 1840, since none of that ever happened.
I'm more with arashi these days though, because delving too deep into this stuff can really confuse you about what's going on with who and where.
And I've always thought that the two Roxanne's were one and the same. It makes total sense.
Speaking of Roxanne, when Barnabas and Julia returned from 1840 and changed the course of history. Roxanne
and Sebastian Shaw will not exist. Roxanne would not be a vampire, chained inside a coffin at the secret room. Shaw
would be living a different life.
You're right of course, but then Barnabas wouldn't be in 1971 either.
Once they return to 1971 from 1840, BC, JH and TES would start to settle into and reacclimate to the new time line, remembering things that happened to them (and didn't) in the past of this new time-line. They may or may not continue to remember the original time-line. I think.