It's Halloween, so I'm thinking about michael c's suggestion that we have a discussion of the 2012 movie today:
deppshadows "watching project"
I've seen the movie twice: once on May 11 in a movie theater, and once on October 2 on DVD. And I've thought about how Johnny Depp watched the series when it was originally broadcast, as I did. Depp and I appear to have been seeing Barnabas completely differently, however.
Johnny Depp's Barnabas seems to me to be unattractive, clueless, and annoying. These are all things that Jonathan Frid's Barnabas was not. I'm not much of a moviewatcher, but I've seen Johnny Depp in a few other movies, and I know that he can be attractive, intelligent, and interesting, even when he's playing a bad guy. A lot of other Dark Shadows fans have loved the movie, so I gather they are seeing things that I am not.
My dislike for Depp's Barnabas causes me to feel that Eva Green's Angelique is all wrong as well. I like her far better than I like Lara Parker's Angelique - but she doesn't make sense. Parker's Angelique is totally self-absorbed. It makes sense that she should have carried the torch for Barnabas for over a century, whatever his faults, because ultimately everything is all about her. Later in the series we see some emotional growth in her, and that's interesting - but in the time of the series that corresponds to the movie, that hasn't happened yet. The movie Angelique is another story. The self-absorption isn't there. So it seems out of character for her to be fixated on an unattractive, clueless, and annoying person like Barnabas.
Would somebody care to set me straight?