71
« on: May 12, 2012, 04:34:37 PM »
I saw it with my family in a packed house Imax showing in Tulsa OK. We all loved it, and the audinace seemed to really enjoy it.
There were a few missteps and things that could've been doen better, but overall it was great fun. It kept some of the mood and spirit of the original but went in different directions with it, which I think worked. A remake should find new ground to explore out of the old material or there's no use in remaking it.
I thought the Maggie/Vicki merger was exciting, I gasped and nearly fell out of my chair over that one lol
I did think that the orphan background should've been kept, and it was odd that they didn't use the oprhan background or "Pop", but Vicki being dumped in an asylum did effect orphan her and made use of Maggie's history with Windcliff.
I thought the characters were used and developed pretty well. I think an extended directors cut could improve things.
Julia needed the most development, HBC was great but Julia just didn't get enough development. I never really felt her relationship with Barnabas and the "on her knees" moment was abrupt and distasteful as it happened too suddenly and made no impact on the plot. Neither Barnabas or Julia even reacted to the scene.
I thought Roger being such a scoundral worked to show him in comparison to Barnabas in their roles in the family. Roger failed as a father and brother, businessman, and Barnabas stepped up into those roles. We saw how much Liz and the kids needed him because Roger had failed them.
I thougth Angelique's china doll breaking apart at the end was really interesting, a unique way of showing her inhumanity. I did think that a little more vulnderability from Angelique would've improved things.
Carolyn's secret was a huge WTF that would've benefited from some foreshadowing, but it still brought some great moments to the movie, providing an explanation for CArolyn's angst and I LOVED how quickly Liz adjusted and accepted it. Werewolf or not Liz loved her child and I cheered when Liz carried Carolyn to safety with no hesitation. I think that some restored footage in a director's cut would really improve that.
Johnny Depp carried the movie beautifully, exploring Barnabas as a man out of time, an outsider trying to find his way, and really the rest of the cast all worked very well I thought.
The plot kept shocking me, with Barnabas being "out" to the family, then publicly exposed, Julia's death and resurrection, Laura, Carolyn, Collinwood burning, the movie's last half hour or so left me on my toes with no idea what was going to happen next.
I liked how the family all came togather with Barnabas against Angelique, and I enjoyed the irony that Angelique had created all her own enemies out of spite, and thus brought about her own destructon, very mytholoigal in scope.
Roll out the sequel!