586
Current Talk '06 II / Re: Leviathan story vs 1970PT story
« on: July 09, 2006, 11:45:38 PM »I mean, can Quentin be more of an a-hole and Maggie more of a DOORMAT!? She makes Beth Chavez look like a bra-burner! I don't understand why the hell she doesn't tell Q to take a flying leap of Widow's Hill and then laugh all the way to the bank w/a huge divorce settlement. That man can't get through a freakin' day w/out shouting at someone, usually her! He makes me want to KICK the TV! Quite a statement to David Selby's acting talent because I *love* RT Quentin, but HATE his PT counterpart! Anyway, mainly I just want to plow through the rest of the plotline to get to 1995 and 1970 RT. BTW, I *love* Leviathan, don't know why it's so maligned in fandom. :-
LOL -- yeah it would be hard for him to be more of an ass and her more of a doormat unless you go back to the original Rebecca. PT is kind of fun for me, cause I like trying to spot all the stuff they swiped.
On the other hand, Leviathan is more original, and satisfying. I think a lot of the problem is it suffers in contract with 1897 and its large multilayered story and (mostly) well developed characters. That said, I do remember offhand certain issues in Leviathan which bugged me. Main one that comes to mind is Professor Stokes not being quite up to his usual reasoning standards. And the way Quentin was wasted in that respect -- anyone with his background, not to mention another 70 years bouncing around the world seeking the cure to his curse would have been contributing much more to the supernatural knowledge needed to save the day. I find it very unlikely that given the places and people he would have been encountering trying to remove his curse, he wouldn't have knowledge or contacts with knowledge who could have been contributing to the efforts.
Then again, I'm the warped person who is of the opinion that Professor Stokes would have (shades of Carolyn in Return to Collinwood) have called in his old professor as well -- and I am of the decided opinion that Stokes did his grad work under one Indiana Jones. Of course, given that Quentin might have encountered Professor Jones as well in his peripatetic travels, that could have been quite an amusing scene -- all and sundry trying to pretend they've never met before.