1221
« on: September 20, 2008, 08:35:56 AM »
So, this half was definitely better than the first. Once again, I must say that the direction and music of this pilot are top quality. Both are exceptional.
This show's whole take on the vampire story is really refreshing. The "experts" are all seemingly open to the possibility of this being a real vampire, and I like that take a lot. It gets the story going a lot quicker, instead of holding everything up by having scenes where everyone is arguing over whether or not the vampire is real.
I am really starting to like Barnabas as a character. I wasn't too sure about him in the first half, but now I think I'll like him. I love Victoria and David even more than I did in the first hour. Both are exceptional. I still don't like Carolyn or Roger. Willie is just sort of annoying. He's supposed to add comic relief, but I think he's a little over-the-top so far. He may get better as time goes on.
There were a couple of things that bothered me. The first thing was how they dressed Elizabeth in a couple of the scenes. Some of her outfits just don't seem to fit the rather regal, strong lady Elizabeth seems to be. Another thing that bothered me was the staircase leading to the basement of the Old House. It looked so modern that it completely threw off my whole sense of immersion. Another quibble I have with this part of the show is how I am unable to tell whether or not I am looking at Collinwood or the Old House. They look exactly the same to me, and it's very confusing. Another little thing that I noticed here that didn't really bother me, but I am thinking is a blooper, is Barnabas returning to look up at Victoria's window without his cane. I can't imagine him walking all the way back to the Old House just to drop off his cane and then come back to hiss at Miss Winters' window. It's entirely possible, but I think they just omitted his cane because of the logistics of the scene; ie: running after Sarah. The problem there is that they made such a point in the previous scene to emphasize the cane, that Barnabas not having it a few minutes later just seems like a big oversight.
There were two wonderful scenes in this part of the pilot. The first was Willie's interrogation. I thought that was a very well directed scene. The other was Barnabas and Victoria in Josette's room. Once again, I have to comment that the music is superb, especially Josette's Music Box theme.
As a side note, I must say that I am watching the DVDs, and the removal of the "night" filters on the day for night scenes doesn't really bother me. I just think of all that excess light as really bright moonlight, and since the setting for this show is really quite surreal, it works in my opinion. My tapes of the original broadcast include the filters, and the heavy blues in those scenes always bothered me, because they made the scenes seem fake.
My grade for this part of the pilot is an A-. Over all, it's great. The few problems I mentioned above don't really take away from the show itself, but the excess "sex appeal" elements written into the script do detract in my opinion. Frankly, I'm not interested in seeing Joe and Daphne swap saliva or Carolyn tease that future victim in the bar. Those things detract from the quality of the show, imo. I want to see character build-up, more emphasis on the family, on Barnabas and Victoria, etc. But, that's just me.