DARK SHADOWS FORUMS

General Discussions => Current Talk Archive => Current Talk '25 I => Current Talk '05 II => Topic started by: McTrooper on July 27, 2005, 04:14:00 PM

Title: If DS got re-edited?
Post by: McTrooper on July 27, 2005, 04:14:00 PM: I was thinking, what if DS got re-edited?

Edited to cut out:
The video re-cap (starting out a minute before the previous show ended) turning two or three episodes into a continuous story.
Scenes that really didn't add to the story or ran longer than needed.

Would something like this kind of editing make it easier to watch (less time) and possibly more exciting to younger generations?

Any thoughts?
Title: Re: If DS got re-edited?
Post by: Darren Gross on July 27, 2005, 04:50:31 PM: Check out the first 8 volumes of the VHS releases (non-collectors series) and you'll see just that!
Title: Re: If DS got re-edited?
Post by: michael c on July 28, 2005, 12:52:43 AM: personally i wouldn't vote for a re-edit.

as darren gross pointed out volumes 1-8 edit out the material not specific to the barnabas storyline.i found that very irritating.the other actor's work deserves to be seen too.remember one man's trash is another man's treasure.

and it's only a half hour show to begin with.minus commercials about 23 minutes.i would hope that our younger generation doesn't have such a shortened attention span that they can't get through a 23 minute show.
plus "unnecessary" things like the re-cap,the voiceover,the credits and even the occasional flub add to the shows distinct feeling. :P
Title: Re: If DS got re-edited?
Post by: FireRose on July 28, 2005, 07:07:33 AM: Re-edit... I would vote no...

Dark Shadows is a classic and you don't tamper with a classic.

You either like it or you don't... Editing it wouldn't make people like it. If they don't like it to begin with. Then they never will.

FireRose
Title: Re: If DS got re-edited?
Post by: Gothick on August 03, 2005, 05:39:58 PM: Those of us who are really diehard fans don't want ANY editing. We want every minute of the series AS AIRED. It's fun when they occasionally manage to retrieve outtakes, as well (check the blooper video for a great one involving Grayson and Jerry Lacy).

It was upsetting to us that some scenes were snipped due to "video glitches" or some other excuse in the first few DVD sets. Apparently this happened because MPI sent the shows out for clean-up. They obviously meant well but there was quite an uproar from the fans who know these shows like the back of their (fill in favorite member).

I think those who just watch the show casually find this sort of thing odd, but hardcore DS'ers do tend to put the FANATIC into FAN.

Best, G.
Title: Re: If DS got re-edited?
Post by: Raineypark on August 03, 2005, 05:49:38 PM: Quote from: Gothick on August 03, 2005, 05:39:58 PM
They obviously meant well but there was quite an uproar from the fans who know these shows like the back of their (fill in favorite member).
[lghy].....Goddess, I do SO love the way you express yourself.
Title: Re: If DS got re-edited?
Post by: stefan on August 07, 2005, 07:05:19 PM: I wouldn't mind seeing some of the really really bad bloopers edited out. I think they can be distracting to the story at hand.
Title: Re: If DS got re-edited?
Post by: Maybellique on August 21, 2005, 10:08:39 PM: Quote from: McTrooper
Would something like this kind of editing make it easier to watch (less time) and possibly more exciting to younger generations?

Any thoughts?

No, in fact I felt gypped knowing the vhs eps had been edited a bit. I found myself wondering what I was missing. ~DJ