DARK SHADOWS FORUMS

General Discussions => Current Talk Archive => Current Talk '24 I => Current Talk '08 II => Topic started by: Watching Project 2 on September 13, 2008, 01:31:02 AM

Title: Discuss: '91 Series - Pilot - Part 1
Post by: Watching Project 2 on September 13, 2008, 01:31:02 AM
[video]
http://www.dsboards.com/1991/Opening_1.swf

(To control the play of the video, right-click on it and use the controls.)
[/video]

(More bits to come...)
Title: Re: Discuss: '91 Series - Pilot - Part 1
Post by: Midnite on September 13, 2008, 02:21:16 AM
What fun!!!
Title: Re: Discuss: '91 Series - Pilot - Part 1
Post by: Gerard on September 13, 2008, 03:11:15 AM
Oh, does that bring back memories!  I was living in Alaska at that time, and made sure that night I had my phone unplugged so no one would disturb me.  Was that actually 16 years ago?

Gerard
Title: Re: Discuss: '91 Series - Pilot - Part 1
Post by: Lydia on September 13, 2008, 03:53:17 AM
Hmm...I can't see what's in the first post because my computer won't let me do that sort of thing.  I've tried to reason with it, but it stands fast.

But I trust that this is still place for discussion, and here I am, ready, willing, and able to discuss.

How did Willie figure out the secret of the secret room?  He didn't appear to have the necessary intelligence, and yet he read stuff and put together clues to figure out something that hadn't been figured out in nearly two hundred years.

I like the idea of the Collinwood mansion coming from England to America at about the time that Barnabas went from America to England.  Yes, I know, Barnabas didn't go to England - but I like the idea, even if it wasn't true, of every action having an opposite (if not equal) reaction in Collins family history.  Or maybe it was a trade: "Hey, England, what's the price on that fine old mansion?"  "Nothing less than your first-born son, Joshua Collins."  "Well, then, you've got yourself a deal!"

I don't think the writers of the show understood how the Vice President of the United States was chosen back in 1796.

Overall, this just doesn't feel like my kind of show.  I don't like the look of the characters.   Oh, well, the male characters tend not to bother me so much.  But the female ones are not my preferred style of Hollywood - with the exception of Maggie Evans.  I suppose I should not judge the characters on appearance alone, but I can't help it.  These are not my sort of people.  I have the same feeling about Buffy the Vampire Slayer.  I've never gotten past the first season of that show.

And the sound quality tends to be harsh.  My ears keep telling me, "You've got better things to do with your time."  I'm watching the DVDs.  Was the sound this harsh on the show as it was broadcast?  Or am I the only one who feels this way?
Title: Re: Discuss: '91 Series - Pilot - Part 1
Post by: michael c on September 13, 2008, 04:31:00 AM
i wasn't planning on doing the watching project II but since i have the dvds i figured why not.

i have to get a few glaring incongruities out of the way first.the show is set in maine but was obviously filmed in the blazing california sun.the "town" of collinsport is soundstage.it looks too glossy.even with all the dry ice it fails to communicate the proper sense of gothic menace.

the fashions are quite dated.vicki's traveling costume.she's wearing a suit with large shoulder pads.i forgot young women still dressed like that then.when she tops this with a similarly padded coat the effect is a rather "stacked" shoulder.carolyn wears miniskirts and black leather biker jackets.this is meant to convey that she is a "rebel" of some sort.elizabeth gets lots of wide-pleat trousers topped with matching caftan-y things.very bea arthur circa "golden girls"of around this same time.

what was socially acceptable behavior has changed somewhat.roger(portrayed here as a total douche)tells a drinking and obviously drunk willie(portrayed here as a slob and a moron)to go pick vicki up at the blue whale putting not just his life but her's in jeopardy.no one there does anything to stop this either.strange putting a girl in the car with a dangerously drunk idiot but whatever.we also learn around this scene that sam evans is committing tax fraud(aided by daphne)but whatever.business intrigue is not going to be part of the recipe.

vicki can handle willie and also the as yet inexplicably psychopathic david.this is meant to convey that she has "spunk".that she grew up in an orphanage is unmentioned in this episode but she was apparently hired by a lawer.no mystery there.david's "pranks" such as hiding in a closet and shouting "boo" and hiding a spider in his desk are pretty routine and not really that scary.the young actor will grow up to be a real hottie(see "mysterious skin").

i didn't think barnabas was that hot when i first watched this but he does have a certain appeal.

strange that they're already mentioning vampires in the pilot.takes alot of the suspence and mystery out of the proceedings when people are already in on it.

o.k. if perfunctory introductions to most characters with enough hints dropped to imply numerous subplots in the future.

i'm sort of with lydia.this wouldn't normally be my type of show.i'm not into vampire stuff in general.but i'll go with the flow in this.
Title: Re: Discuss: '91 Series - Pilot - Part 1
Post by: Midnite on September 13, 2008, 05:26:39 AM
For those of you watching on DVD, here are several scenes not included in Sony's version that are just from the first hour!  There's some exposition that provides backstory (it certainly did for me the first time I saw the series with these scenes restored) and a bit more character development, especially for Roger and Carolyn.


In an extension of the scene in the drawing room, Elizabeth tells Roger that David needs a family,... and a father!  He reveals that last night, he talked his son into joining him on a walk along the beach at dusk, though he was surprised David agreed.  Roger talked about Europe, about his own childhood-- anything he could think of, but David was silent until he pulled on Roger's arm to ask one question-- if he liked him.  "If I liked him," he repeats.  Elizabeth assures him that in time they'll get to know each other, but Roger says, "I'm not so sure, dear sister."  Then, "I'll try to say this so that I'm still left with a shred of dignity," he adds, and confesses to feeling resentment that his son is alive; "May the Lord forgive me," he says, "but if it would have saved her sanity, I would have left him to die in that burning room."  Elizabeth is speechless.

Joe leaves the Blue Whale to watch Vicki get into Willie's pickup.  Willie: "Night, loverboy.  Hee hee hee."  Vicki waves, and Willie speeds off.  Joe stomps inside, calling Willie a jerk who needs to learn some manners... "especially if he's gonna mess with someone crazier than him."  He makes Daphne giggle, then slings her over his shoulder to carry her to his car for some "night fishing."  Maggie calls it "just another night at the Blue Whale."

The ladies are having tea when Vicki asks how long David has been without his father.  Elizabeth says about 6 years.  She brought him back from England when his mother took ill, and it has been hard on him.  She calls him a bright boy with an amazing imagination, and Carolyn responds, "If you can call putting garter snakes in my dresser imaginative."  Vicki and Roger are introduced, and her compliment of Collinwood prompts Roger to explain that Elizabeth always had a gift for maintaining the house in the grand manner.  Elizabeth says, "Style should be the dress of thought.  It tempers life with grace."  She looks to Vicki, who agrees and then asks if a painting on an easel is a Seurat.  Elizabeth says it's a copy, and Roger interrupts with "it was painted by another artist."  Vicki looks at it more closely and declares that it's very good.  Roger asks if she enjoys art, and she answers that it's one of her favorite teaching subjects; "I think that children express themselves very well through drawing and painting."  Roger says he supposes she gets to know them better, and Vicki says they get to know themselves-- that's the challenge.  Roger tells her he thinks his son is as much a challenge as she can handle; he's certain he is different from any boy she has taught.  Roger excuses himself for the night, and Carolyn smirks.

We see an upstairs light on at Collinwood.  As Vicki unpacks, Carolyn enters with blankets, saying it gets cold at night.  She says the fireplace works and describes the bathroom as big enough for a battalion.  Vicki:  "Thanks.  I really can't wait to meet David."  Carolyn:  "Oh yes, you can."  Vicki hopes he'll like her, and Carolyn says he will or he'll have to answer to her.  Carolyn: "Vicki, I'm really glad you're here."  "So am I."  An animal howls, and Vicki asks what it was.  Carolyn:  "The strange creatures of the Maine woods.  When the moon is full and the wolfbane blooms, they come down from the mountains out of the cold.  Ow-woooooo!"  A dog barks, and Vicki looks out to see a tall figure in old-fashioned clothes standing in the fog.  She says that someone is standing at the edge of the wood.  Carolyn checks but Barnabas is gone.  V:  "I thought I saw someone."  C:  "You're in the boonies, kid.  This place can have that kind of effect on you."  She says Vicki must be tired and suggests she take a bath and rest, and sounding very sincere, she adds that if she needs anything, she need only call.  Alone now, Vicki looks out of the window again.

In addition to the sight of Daphne in her hospital bed, we see the sign outside that reads Collinsport Mercy Hospital.  As a worried Joe keeps vigil at her beside, Hiram tells him there's nothing he can do there now and suggests he head to the lounge and get a cup of coffee, but Joe prefers to stay.  The doc says he'll look in on her later.

After Carolyn and Elizabeth enter the hospital room, the latter strokes Daphne followed by a closeup of Elizabeth's anguished face.

Rain can be heard as Vicki enters the dining room and first greets Mrs. Johnson, who is is putting the final touches on a large breakfast buffet, and then Roger, who is seated at a formally set table.  Vicki asks there's been any word about Daphne, and Roger answers that they were promised a call if there's any change.  Roger puts down his newspaper and says he assumes she has met David by now, asking what she thinks of him.  "To be honest," Vicki replies, "he started by trying to scare the living daylights out of me, and he hit the jackpot."  Roger offers to talk to him, but she says there's no need-- that little boys have terrorized teachers and babysitters forever, and mischief goes with the territory.  Roger tells her that David is a very difficult child.  She says she's sure it hasn't been easy for David, and she asks him to give her some time because she feels it's best to not expect too much too soon.  Roger:  "I learned a long time ago never to expect anything.  That way, I'm never disappointed."

Sheriff Patterson makes the drive in a downpour to Collinwood and tells Roger and Elizabeth that he's looking for Willie Loomis, who was acting strangely at the Blue Whale the previous night.  After an introduction to Vicki, Patterson says she must have witnessed Willie almost taking a swing at Joe Haskell, but she tells him that nothing really happened.  Elizabeth says, "I don't understand;" she thought they were looking for an animal, but Patterson says they were wrong about that.  Elizabeth asks what kind of person could have done such a thing, then questions how he could seriously think that Willie could have anything to do with it.  He tells her he never said that.  Roger offers to accompany Patterson to the stables to look for Willie, and as they leave, Elizabeth and Vicki take each other's hands.  At the stables, the men spot Willie's truck and head upstairs.  They find the empty room in a mess, and Roger says Willie is a strange young man.  He picks up a couple of empties and says he's probably sleeping it off somewhere.  The sheriff tells Roger that when he sees him, he should tell him to come to the station house.
Title: Re: Discuss: '91 Series - Pilot - Part 1
Post by: Taeylor Collins on September 13, 2008, 06:23:59 AM
Hey guys.  I wrote two pages (front and back) and set here for the last 45 minutes editing and typing it out.  Well I lost it. So I am gonna come back tomorrow and post my review.  I am so pissed. [ghost_mad] I have been having internet problems all day or I would have posted earlier.  Here in the south it is late.   [ghost_sleep]

we also learn around this scene that sam evans is committing tax fraud(aided by daphne)but whatever.business intrigue is not going to be part of the recipe.

I personally think your assuming that. I think he was saying he couldn't do his own taxes as she appears to be an accountant. Without an accountant I would probably screw my taxes up as well and be in jail.  Just my opinion though.

Quote
i didn't think barnabas was that hot when i first watched this but he does have a certain appeal.

I think Ben is gorgeous then and now.  He has aged well.

Quote
strange that they're already mentioning vampires in the pilot.takes a lot of the suspense and mystery out of the proceedings when people are already in on it

Why is it strange?  At this point in time our culture has been inundated with vampire lore. I think it's very natural.

Here are some screencaps I took from the show.  Hope you all enjoy them!! Of course I had to include two of Joanna.  She is one of the most striking woman I have ever seen.  By the way thanks Midnite as I am viewing the DVDS.  You rock!!
Title: Re: Discuss: '91 Series - Pilot - Part 1
Post by: Midnite on September 13, 2008, 06:27:41 AM
i have to get a few glaring incongruities out of the way first.the show is set in maine but was obviously filmed in the blazing california sun.the "town" of collinsport is soundstage.it looks too glossy.

The pilot was filmed in March, when the temps in Southern California are pretty mild-- usually in the 70s, not counting this year.  It can also be our wettest month, again not counting this year.  ::)

Which Collinsport scenes are you thinking about when you say they were shot on a soundstage?  I honestly can't think of one that wasn't shot either on location somewhere or on a backlot.

Letting Willie drive after he's obviously been drinking bugged my more modern sensibility too.  So did Roger smoking at the breakfast table, ugh.

Quote
strange that they're already mentioning vampires in the pilot.takes alot of the suspence and mystery out of the proceedings when people are already in on it.

I suspect the issue was addressed quickly because the sheriff was already questioning why the killer extracted 2 liters of blood from Daphne's neck and took it away from the scene, so the writers had Woodard bring up the matter of irrational people who think themselves to be vampires and drink human blood.  (Who knew, back then, that a vampire culture would become mainstream?)  It also lets the viewers know that in the show's universe, clearly the characters are aware that vampirism exists.  What do others think about the mention of the v-word so early?  And did anyone else fine it refreshing to have someone in a vampire movie finally ask where the victim's blood went?
Title: Re: Discuss: '91 Series - Pilot - Part 1
Post by: Cousin_Barnabas on September 13, 2008, 08:17:18 AM
Direction:  First of all, let me say that the direction of this episode was fantastic.  The whole setting seems sort of "dream-like", while maintaining a strict sense of reality.  That balance is very important to maintain.  Secondly, the music is superb, one of the best "mystery/horror" scores I have ever heard.  The direction and music is perfect for what I've watched so far.

Characters:  There are some characters/actors I already know I will like.  Joanna Going as Victoria is definitely going to be one of my favorites, as well as Jean Simmons as Liz, Mrs. Johnson, and little David.  I want to like Barnabas Collins, but I can't say that I do just yet.  Perhaps it's how Ben Cross carries himself that makes me sort of "stand-off-ish" when it comes to this character.  I haven't seen enough of either Cross or Barnabas yet to determine if I will like him.  Some characters I don't really care for right now are Carolyn and Roger.  I'm sort of indifferent towards some of the lesser characters and Willie.  My main problem with Willie is how he is involved in the plot. 

Plot/Story:  The overall premise of this series is a great one, one I really like.  It's got a big mansion, a spooky family, lots of secrets, and a vampire.  I did have a few problems with the storyline for this episode though, mainly how the character of Willie is involved.  First of all, I think the writers made a big mistake having the Collins family send an incompetent drunk to pick up a new employee.  It doesn't seem like something either Elizabeth or Roger would do.  It is classless and senseless.  I understand that the writers wanted to tie the character in with the rest of the story, maybe add a little depth to him, but there had to be a better way.   A family like the Collinses isn't going to do this, no way, no how.  It just wouldn't happen.  I also have a problem with how Victoria would be stupid enough to place her life in danger by riding with Willie when she could clearly see how drunk he was.  I can see how it might show a compassionate, understanding, "give him a chance" type side of Vicki, but it also makes her seem stupid, when the rest of the time, the character is not.  Another problem I had (also involving Willie) was how he figured out that the lion was the central part of the riddle.  Logically, from the way the poem is written, the key to the riddle would be the dove, not the lion's head (especially when it comes to the placement of the dove in the scene.  It was bigger than the lion.)  So, those things made very little sense to me.  I can overlook them though, because the rest of the show is making up for these poorly written character actions. 

My grade of this episode:  B
Title: Re: Discuss: '91 Series - Pilot - Part 1
Post by: Philippe Cordier on September 13, 2008, 08:37:49 AM
I haven't finished watching the first episode yet with my new DVDs.  I quickly skimmed through Midnite's summarizing of missing scenes (which had been restored on the VHS release but not on the DVDs).  Wow!  I hadn't realized so much was missing when I began watching earlier this week - a few years have passed since I viewed the series on VHS.  Watching it now, I felt the pacing was good and tight ... but from some of the things Midnite wrote -- for example, Roger telling Elizabeth about his talk with David -- I would agree that much of the backstory and character development got cut before the pilot aired (and restored only on the VHS version).  I remember some of those scenes now from my earlier viewing of the VHS.

Reading other's comments, I find myself nodding in agreement with almost everything.  Then, when I read the next comment taking another view, I also say "uh-huh!"  There's so much here, though, I don't know where to begin ... so I'll try to finish watching and get back here tomorrow night.

The things I had been thinking about so far were as follows:

I like the DVD packaging with its portrayal of Collinwood (but not of Ben Cross - it looks silly).  I wonder what they used for Collinwood for the DVD cover - it looks more like computerized artwork than a real house, but it's very scary looking.  The brief glimpse I've had so far of the actual Collinwood of the series is that it looks fake (I know it's a model, and they put a lot of work into it, but it still looks like a model.  Wish they could have filmed a real house.)

The bats are scary - and, incidentally, are playing a role where I'm living now.  I've never lived anywhere where there were large amounts of bats - until now.  I wouldn't have known what the horrible sound was had not one of the movers told me "it sounds like bats out there."  There must be thousands.  As I left the clubhouse last night and was walking accross the green to my apartment just after dusk, I could see them flitting through the air.  When they fly they make only a few twittering sounds.  One of them brushed the top of my head.  It wasn't scary seeing how small they are - but at night when it's warm, I have to shut my bedroom window because they are so loud when they are in the trees.  It sounds like sort of a rubbery chomping.

Inside the DVD case, the picture of Vicki under the first DVD is really beautiful.  I think she was a nice choice to play Victoria.  I am finding Carolyn less irritating this viewing - in fact, I'm finding her attitude rather amusing.  Stay tuned, because I couldn't stand her when I first watched the series.

The scary scenes seem frightening in a realistic and violent way - like when Daphne gets attacked.  I'm not sure, I think I like a little more distance and unreality in my vampire movies.

Another thought was on the cropping of the top and bottom of the frame on the DVDs.  Something looks strange about it - it doesn't look quite the same as a widescreen movie, something about the composition of the shots.  I would have preferred the full frame as it was shot for TV.

I'm not sure if I'll be able to tell when the first episode is over.  I was surprised that there weren't any opening credits.  I've gotten to the scene where Barnabas says something like, "Father, I'm home."  I think the first episode on the VHS was about two hours but don't know how long it was in actual broadcast and on the DVDs.

Title: Re: Discuss: '91 Series - Pilot - Part 1
Post by: Taeylor Collins on September 13, 2008, 08:51:46 AM
I think the part when Barney arrives at THE OLD HOUSE is actually where we stop watching for our first part.  I need to go announcment page.  Also this looks like LETTERBOX instead of WIDESCREEN although I may be wrong.
Title: Re: Discuss: '91 Series - Pilot - Part 1
Post by: Nelson Collins on September 13, 2008, 02:03:42 PM
we also learn around this scene that sam evans is committing tax fraud(aided by daphne)
Forgive me, but where did you get that impression?!?  The impression I get is that Sam is hopeless at accounting, and without Daphne's help (who seems to be the number cruncher of the Collins family), the books would be so mismanaged that he'd be in trouble (hence the humorous line that that without her help he'd be in jail).  At no point is there any indication (to me anyway) that Sam and Daphne are trying to cheat the government.
Title: Re: Discuss: '91 Series - Pilot - Part 1
Post by: Mysterious Benefactor on September 13, 2008, 02:18:26 PM
Hmm...I can't see what's in the first post because my computer won't let me do that sort of thing.  I've tried to reason with it, but it stands fast.

That video is 12.37MB, so depending on the Internet connection speed, it can take quite a while to download.


I think the part when Barney arrives at THE OLD HOUSE is actually where we stop watching for our first part.

That's where we stop for this topic.  [ghost_smiley]
Title: Re: Discuss: '91 Series - Pilot - Part 1
Post by: Watching Project on September 13, 2008, 02:32:28 PM
To give even more of the full original experience, here are Part 1's commercial bumpers that give a peek at what's to come in the next act or simply identify the show:

[video]
http://www.dsboards.com/1991/0113_Bumper_1.swf

(To control the play of the video, right-click on it and use the controls.)
[/video]
(Along with Domino's announcing its major sponsorship.)

[video]
http://www.dsboards.com/1991/0113_Bumper_2.swf

(To control the play of the video, right-click on it and use the controls.)
[/video]

[video]
http://www.dsboards.com/1991/0113_Bumper_3.swf

(To control the play of the video, right-click on it and use the controls.)
[/video]

[video]
http://www.dsboards.com/1991/0113_Bumper_4.swf

(To control the play of the video, right-click on it and use the controls.)
[/video]

[video]
http://www.dsboards.com/1991/0113_Bumper_5.swf

(To control the play of the video, right-click on it and use the controls.)
[/video]
Title: Re: Discuss: '91 Series - Pilot - Part 1
Post by: Taeylor Collins on September 13, 2008, 04:09:24 PM
MB I wish my original tapes would have held up as well.  When I was young though I wasn't aware you could tape shows on a slower speed.  SILLY ME!  Oh well....I had to throw my tapes out because they were wornout by me in the summer of '91 (when my parents made me quit watching because they thought I was obsessed LOL) and all through the years.  I think they dry rotted!!  I am gonna post later.....I have not rested well and am gonna nap.  I am loving everyones comments so far!  You guys rock.  And once again thank you MB and Midnite for doing this project! I hope we hear some comments from both of you all.  Hope you are able to put your 2 cents in and not just respond to what others have written.  It would be cool to hear a review from either of you.  Or I think it would!  [ghost_wink]
Title: Re: Discuss: '91 Series - Pilot - Part 1
Post by: Miss_Winthrop on September 13, 2008, 04:11:52 PM
Well, I've certanly enjoyed reading the comments thus far!  I too take issue with Sam Evans commiting tax fraud.  I just get the impression that Daphne is helping him get the tax breaks he deserves.  After all, if she's employed by the Collinses (and here is where I'm a little confused about her status at  Collinwood), she must know what she's doing.  My confusion regarding Daphne's status is, she has to be exceptionally close to the family in order for Liz to open up a room for her recovery which is very much inkeeping with a gracious Liz Stoddard. Perhaps Daphne has no family.  But I recall that the Sheriff (ooh, I really like his character a lot!) calls her the 'Collins' girl. I don't have a problem with Willie going to pick up Miss Winters.  I think once he was roughed up by Roger he became sober very quickly!  He certainly wasn't drunk while he was at the Blue Whale.  He just acted like a tough guy with  low self-esteem.  As for Roger, he didn't want Miss Winters in the house anyway so her safety in being driven by Willie probably never even crossed his mind.  David: I like the actor portraying him but I think he overacts in certain scenes and I find him a little hard to believe.  Carolyn: At first she seemed high on drugs. But after awhile I warmed up to her as just a bored Collins who for some reason left a glamorous like (perhaps in NYC) returned hom at the behest of her mother and just looked for opportunities to try and be witty or profound. Since the story takes place in Maine and a lot of people associate the state with mysterious happenings and old wives tale. The bringing up of a 'Vampire' doesn't seem out of place since we know that human saliva and not that of an animal is found in the wounds.  I'm appreciating the 'pilot' a lot more than the first time around.  
Title: Re: Discuss: '91 Series - Pilot - Part 1
Post by: Midnite on September 13, 2008, 04:24:41 PM
The bats are scary - and, incidentally, are playing a role where I'm living now.  I've never lived anywhere where there were large amounts of bats - until now.  I wouldn't have known what the horrible sound was had not one of the movers told me "it sounds like bats out there."  There must be thousands.  As I left the clubhouse last night and was walking accross the green to my apartment just after dusk, I could see them flitting through the air.  When they fly they make only a few twittering sounds.  One of them brushed the top of my head.  It wasn't scary seeing how small they are - but at night when it's warm, I have to shut my bedroom window because they are so loud when they are in the trees.  It sounds like sort of a rubbery chomping.

Now that's freakin' creepy.
Title: Re: Discuss: '91 Series - Pilot - Part 1
Post by: Taeylor Collins on September 13, 2008, 05:05:32 PM
I'm appreciating the 'pilot' a lot more than the first time around.  

That is so great to hear! :)  Some more pics......My review will come up later.  I hope you all are enjoying the pics.  IF not or if they are taking up too much space let me know.  I enjoy sharing them with all of my cousins!  [ghost_grin]
Title: Re: Discuss: '91 Series - Pilot - Part 1
Post by: Nelson Collins on September 13, 2008, 05:15:40 PM
First of all, mea culpa. I misunderstood the original instructions and thought the double length DVD episode 1 was split into two eps and ended up watching the whole thing.  If I stray into second part of the pilot details here, apologies in advance.

As I indicated in a previous thread, I was away from home last night and ended up watching the episode with a complete virgin.  Not only had he never watched or heard of the Revival, he was surprised when I told him this was a retelling of a storyline from the original series!  He had not heard of that either!

In a way that helps, because I had a "controlled" watching experience.  I will give his reactions first.

He liked the atmosphere at first, the misty almost dreamlike quality that suffused the episode.  However, when mist/fog was present in even interior scenes, (floating behind Mrs. Johnson’s head when she is rebuking Willie) it broke the spell for him and he starting mocking it.  He also commented on how stereotypical the scary movie/vampire movie set pieces were.  Personally, as a fan of the Dracula story in the series Cliffhangers, unlike my friend, I rather liked the old set pieces put into a modern setting.

By the end point of the first part of the pilot, about the only person he liked was Barnabas.  Willie was so in contrast with the rest of the relatively cleancut cast that he stood out even more, not even as comic relief but as just slimy, dirty, almost joke bad teeth and offputting and the rest of the cast were rather bland.  He suggested a continuity game at one point.  Seeing the zits/moles on Willie’s face, he suggested that sharp-eyed viewers might want to check those blemishes in every scene to see if they moved!

Below are the notes I jotted as I watched part 1 of the pilot again this morning.

End of Notes

Taking this episode on its own terms, character-wise, apart from Willie, Barnabas and possibly David, the rest of the cast were all ciphers.  The VHS adds more insight to Roger or at least hints at places his character might go.  But confining myself to this one part of the story, I didn’t find any of the characters apart the three above of much interest.  Victoria’s opening voiceover hints that she is looking to find out about her past but nothing else in this episode deals with even so much as a hint of any other mystery.  She is there only to take care of David and be a beauty that catches Barn’s eye.  At this point no one else is anything special.  The writers focus on the scary set pieces and vampire story to the detriment of everything and everyone else.  Even other nighttime soaps of the time spent time on developing several ongoing storylines/characters and did so right out of the gate.

To be brutally frank, if I didn’t already know what was in store, on the basis of this one part of the pilot alone, I probably wouldn’t watch any more.
Title: Re: Discuss: '91 Series - Pilot - Part 1
Post by: Gerard on September 13, 2008, 05:49:41 PM
One thing that always bugged me [about DS] is Barnabas' arrival at the front door of Collinwood, in 20th century clothing, cool as a cucumber, able to convince everyone that he's from there own time, when he had been released - what? - just about 48 hours earlier from his coffin.  The last things he remembers are whale oil lamps, horses and carriages, parlor games for entertainment, needing a week to travel to Boston, cooking a basic meal requiring hours of preparation, corsettes and frilly sleeves, period English.  Suddenly he's thrust into an alien world of electricity, cars, television, getting to Europe in six hours, frozen foods, permanent press, and terms like "groovy," "far-out," "cable-ready," and "tex-mess".  One would think he would be a tad overwhelmed and in need of a pretty extensive brusher course on 20th/21st century living before trying to fit in.  Undoubtedly, he made Willie give him a few pointers, but would he get enough in two-to-three days (actually nights) to allow him to fake it that good?  Oh, and how did know how to open Daphne's car door when he had been out of the big box for just a few hours?  He wouldn't even know what a car was, let alone how to work the handle that quickly.

Gerard

[edited by admin]
Title: Re: Discuss: '91 Series - Pilot - Part 1
Post by: Nelson Collins on September 13, 2008, 06:32:51 PM
Interesting you should mention that, Gerard.  I was just thinking that this morning rewatching the pilot part 1, and when Barn was approaching the house, I suddenly wondered if (like the vamps in the recent Underworld series) vampires take more than just nourishment from their victims' blood, absorbing memories and experiences as well?
Title: Re: Discuss: '91 Series - Pilot - Part 1
Post by: Mysterious Benefactor on September 13, 2008, 06:43:50 PM
Please keep in mind the one of the major stipulations is that this project exclusively focuses on the '91 series as a stand alone version of DS. Please, no mentions of any other version of DS - not even in passing or by inference. For our intents and purposes, the '91 DS is the only DS.  [ghost_wink]
Title: Re: Discuss: '91 Series - Pilot - Part 1
Post by: Nelson Collins on September 13, 2008, 06:49:16 PM
Point of order - I've tried studiously to treat the revival as the only DS for the purposes of this project, but other vampire genre shows/films have crept into my comments.  That's okay isn't it?

Your obedient servant,
Nelson Collins
Title: Re: Discuss: '91 Series - Pilot - Part 1
Post by: Mysterious Benefactor on September 13, 2008, 07:50:22 PM
For those of you watching on DVD, here are several scenes not included in Sony's version that are just from the first hour!

There are also a few bits and pieces that were shot that are not even included on MPI's VHS. They are:

Quote
In an extension of the scene in the drawing room, Elizabeth tells Roger that David needs a family,... and a father!  He reveals that last night, he talked his son into joining him on a walk along the beach at dusk, though he was surprised David agreed.  Roger talked about Europe, about his own childhood-- anything he could think of, but David was silent until he pulled on Roger's arm to ask one question-- if he liked him.  "If I liked him," he repeats.
"I went down on my knees and grabbed him and squeezed him as hard as I could. I said, 'David... David, you're my son. I love you. I love you more than anything else in this world." Close - Elizabeth - There are tears in her eyes. Back to Roger, as he continues, "And you know what he did? He just pulled away from me and ran off up the beach... and disappeared over the rocks."
Quote
Elizabeth assures him that in time they'll get to know each other, but Roger says, "I'm not so sure, dear sister."  Then, "I'll try to say this so that I'm still left with a shred of dignity," he adds, and confesses to feeling resentment that his son is alive; "May the Lord forgive me," he says, "but if it would have saved her sanity, I would have left him to die in that burning room."  Elizabeth is speechless.
Quote
Joe leaves the Blue Whale to watch Vicki get into Willie's pickup.  Willie: "Night, loverboy.  Hee hee hee."  Vicki waves, and Willie speeds off.  Joe stomps inside, calling Willie a jerk who needs to learn some manners... "especially if he's gonna mess with someone crazier than him."  He makes Daphne giggle, then slings her over his shoulder to carry her to his car for some "night fishing."  Maggie calls it "just another night at the Blue Whale."
Interior Car: As Joe pulls open the back door, dumps her on the seat, quickly climbs in, shutting the door behind him. Daphne, laughing, "Joe... You are crazy..." He grabs her, plants a hard, smouldering kiss on her. Daphne, quiet, more serious, "I thought you had to go." Joe, "I do." He kisses her again, softer and more earnest this time, "But that doesn't mean I want to." Daphne looks up at him, runs her fingers through his hair, then slowly pulls him back down on her. Daphne, "That's good..." They kiss, long and steaming this time.

[This scene immediately follows the previous one.]
Interior Pickup - Moving - Night: The truck rumbles along the road, its dim headlights barely keeping ahead of them. Willie glances at Vicki, giving her a long once-over. Willie, "Cold out tonight." She looks at him and holds it as he leans over and punches open the glove compartment. Taking out a pint of Wild Turkey, he unscrews the cap, slugs at it, then offers it to her. Vicki, "No thank you." He smiles, takes another, longer belt, wipes his mouth with the back of his sleeve. Willie, "Collinsport's a dump!" He looks at her; she doesn't respond. Willie, "Fulla creeps, like lover boy back there. Collinwood ain't no better. Small town, small minds. (A grin) Know what I mean?" Vicki, "I haven't really seen enough of it to say." Willie, "You will. And anybody give you any hassle, you need somebody to set 'em straight, I'm the guy. Okay?" Vicki pauses a beat, concludes that humor is the best policy, and nods. Vicki, "Okay." Willie smiles, glad that he's making headway.
Exterior Collinwood Grounds - Night: The pickup turns into the long driveway to the house...


[This scene continues from Willie stalking out of the kitchen and leaving his aunt.]
Close - Mrs. Johnson: As she stands there watching him go, she shakes her head sadly, "May God help you - I certainly can't."
Interior Great Hall: As Willie enters from the direction of the kitchen, stops in front of a large portrait done in somber blues and blacks. It is the brooding figure of an eighteenth century man, a cape around his shoulders, a silver wolfhead cane in his hands, a large distinctive black stone ring on his finger. Willie stands there for a beat, staring up at the dark eyes. Willie mutters, "I got you now, mister... I got you now..." And he turns, starts toward the big, front doors. Camera holds on the portrait. And then begins a slow move to the eyes... as a low thumping sound of a heart beat begins to filter in...
Quote
The ladies are having tea when Vicki asks how long David has been without his father.  Elizabeth says about 6 years.  She brought him back from England when his mother took ill, and it has been hard on him.  She calls him a bright boy with an amazing imagination, and Carolyn responds, "If you can call putting garter snakes in my dresser imaginative."  Vicki and Roger are introduced, and her compliment of Collinwood prompts Roger to explain that Elizabeth always had a gift for maintaining the house in the grand manner.  Elizabeth says, "Style should be the dress of thought.  It tempers life with grace."  She looks to Vicki, who agrees and then asks if a painting on an easel is a Seurat.  Elizabeth says it's a copy, and Roger interrupts with "it was painted by another artist."  Vicki looks at it more closely and declares that it's very good.  Roger asks if she enjoys art, and she answers that it's one of her favorite teaching subjects; "I think that children express themselves very well through drawing and painting."  Roger says he supposes she gets to know them better, and Vicki says they get to know themselves-- that's the challenge.  Roger tells her he thinks his son is as much a challenge as she can handle; he's certain he is different from any boy she has taught.  Roger excuses himself for the night, and Carolyn smirks.

When Barnabas is explaining about Collinwood's history, after he mentions the marble: "This wainscotting was fashioned from the richest Baltic woods and" then he continues on about the windows.
Later in the same scene, after Liz gets excited about the family's first home coming back to life, "And you could stay here while the work was being done, God knows we have the room." Barnabas (a beat), "A generous offer... But I've already taken rooms at the Inn. (A beat). I may even be able to make a portion of the house habitable soon enough so that I could actually move in there."
Title: Re: Discuss: '91 Series - Pilot - Part 1
Post by: Mysterious Benefactor on September 13, 2008, 07:51:22 PM
but other vampire genre shows/films have crept into my comments.  That's okay isn't it?

Sure.
Title: Re: Discuss: '91 Series - Pilot - Part 1
Post by: Midnite on September 13, 2008, 10:07:51 PM
There are also a few bits and pieces that were shot that are not even included on MPI's VHS. They are:
...
"I went down on my knees and grabbed him and squeezed him as hard as I could. I said, 'David... David, you're my son. I love you. I love you more than anything else in this world." Close - Elizabeth - There are tears in her eyes. Back to Roger, as he continues, "And you know what he did? He just pulled away from me and ran off up the beach... and disappeared over the rocks."

I read about this scene in the episode guide inside DS Resurrected, though it was presented as being a part of the video release, which is obviously a mistake (though PomPress' reputation remains intact, lol).  But I'm glad it was dropped before filming because it just doesn't work for me.  When you love a child above all worldly things-- above your partner, above yourself, above money or power or anything, you would not consider allowing them to die horribly as a possible tradeoff for their other parent's mental health.  As long as Roger is portrayed as an aloof and selfish bastard who has a non-existent relationship with a dangerously troubled son, it's still a totally messed up choice but one that I can see him making at this point in the story, especially when there's a supernatural element to it that's not yet clear.  But I don't buy that he would entertain the idea for a son he professes to deeply love.

BTW, I caught something on a 2nd viewing of the VHS that I can't believe I missed, but it should be included in my description of scenes not on the DVD.  While Elizabeth attends to the ailing Daphne in the hospital, Carolyn makes a beeline for Joe, kissing his face while he pulls away.  Now that is very telling!

Nelson picked up on some very interesting details.  So here's my pet peeve, though I'm going to guess I'm alone on this one unless jennifer or Carol are watching along too.  While Daphne is incoherent due to a massive blood loss and her doctor claims to still be pumping whole blood into her as quickly as he prudently can, WHY did they use the sound of a pulse monitor beeping at a very normal 80 beats a minute?  How hard is it to find a stock recording of tachycardia?!
Title: Re: Discuss: '91 Series - Pilot - Part 1
Post by: Zahir on September 13, 2008, 10:18:22 PM
I am a big fan of backstory.  When I read Harry Potter, one of the joys in it for me is details like the other Magick Schools.

But this one leaves a great big question mark in my mind.  Where does Daphne fit in?

You've got Elizabeth and her brother Roger.  Elizabeth has a daughter, Carolyn.  Roger has a son, David.

So--who is Daphne Collins?
Title: Re: Discuss: '91 Series - Pilot - Part 1
Post by: Nelson Collins on September 13, 2008, 10:29:49 PM
There are also a few bits and pieces that were shot that are not even included on MPI's VHS. They are:
I got the distinct impression from both the dvd and the VHS (I found and watched Pilot part 1 earlier this afternoon) that there was something unseen in the pick up between Victoria and Willie.

Interesting that there is that continuation of the scene on the beach with David and Roger.  Just reading it, it sounds too hokey for words!  [ghost_tongue2]

A couple of comments on the VHS version of Pilot Part 1:  The additional scenes greatly improve the part 1, being all character bits that make the show overall more interesting, sufficiently so, that I change my mind.  I probably wouldn't have given up on the series if it was the VHS version I had seen first.  Although, in the longer scene between Victoria and Carolyn I couldn't decide if Carolyn was welcoming her or trying to seduce her.  She really came across as a bit predatory.  At this moment, I really am wondering if Carolyn is lesbian, especially with the absence of the kissing Joe scene at the hospital.

I know things sometimes have to be trimmed for time but it's a crying shame that more often than not, it the bits that make the characters seem more human and interesting that are left out.  (Star Trek: The Motion Picture comes immediately to my mind in this regard.  The theatrical release is a bit of a chore to get through, but when when I saw the extended version some years later, the 11 minutes they put back in were all character and exposition, that not only made the characters more real to me, but now the film made a lot more sense!)
Title: Re: Discuss: '91 Series - Pilot - Part 1
Post by: Mysterious Benefactor on September 13, 2008, 10:47:39 PM
BTW, I caught something on a 2nd viewing of the VHS that I can't believe I missed, but it should be included in my description of scenes not on the DVD.  While Elizabeth attends to the ailing Daphne in the hospital, Carolyn makes a beeline for Joe, kissing his face while he pulls away.  Now that is very telling!

I have that down on my notes from finally getting around to watching the first half of the pilot this morning. I'd never noticed it before either [6184] - and I agree that it's very telling. (And it's also very in keeping with what's to come up in Eps #3 & #5. Who knew it had already been established in the pilot?)


The additional scenes greatly improve the part 1, being all character bits that make the show overall more interesting

This is purely my own deduction based on a couple bits of evidence as I've not read this mentioned anywhere and I've never spoken to any fans from other countries who've seen the pilot, but I strongly suspect that all the bits that appear on MPI's VHS but which weren't shown on NBC's broadcast were actually shown in every other country where the '91 series was shown (and it was shown in numerous other countries). I say this because 1) they were scored - meaning that at some point they were a part of the US version, and 2) the running time for the pilot in other countries is listed as being longer by several minutes than it was here. And if I can go one step further, I also strongly suspect that those bits were cut so that Domino's could run more of their commercials during the mini-series so as to maximize their arrangement/investment with NBC.
Title: Re: Discuss: '91 Series - Pilot - Part 1
Post by: michael c on September 14, 2008, 02:35:58 AM
midnite...

the scene where daphne is walking to her car looked very fake to me.the grass was too green and glossy.perhaps "soundstage" was not the right word but to me it looked like a set.

i've lived in california and i've lived in maine.the play of the sunlight and the foliage are totally different.there's not mistaking that this was filmed in california.the dry ice doesn't help.

the scene with sam and daphne and sam's crack about "going to jail" left the vague impression that they were "cooking the books" so to speak.but the tax fraud comment was meant in jest.an off-the-cuff remark about a throw-away scene.i'm surprised it's being taken seriously.
Title: Re: Discuss: '91 Series - Pilot - Part 1
Post by: Mysterious Benefactor on September 14, 2008, 02:47:25 AM
the scene where daphne is walking to her car looked very fake to me.the grass was too green and glossy.perhaps "soundstage" was not the right word but to me it looked like a set.

Actually, that entire sequence was shot outdoors on the Columbia Ranch.  [ghost_smiley]

Quote
the dry ice doesn't help.

That effect was created with smoke, not dry ice. Barbara Steele even joked that the entire cast would probably need Iron Lungs by the time the series wrapped.  [ghost_cheesy]
Title: Re: Discuss: '91 Series - Pilot - Part 1
Post by: michael c on September 14, 2008, 02:49:55 AM
oh..

and i guess having 'vampires' mentioned in the pilot bugs because the proper sense of mystery and suspense is not being established.i prefer a slower buildup.it's too quick.

having people 'on' to the main mystery twenty minutes into series is hasty storytelling to me.but that's just my opinion.
Title: Re: Discuss: '91 Series - Pilot - Part 1
Post by: Mysterious Benefactor on September 14, 2008, 03:04:14 AM
As far as the vampire issue goes, the writers felt that the audience for the show would be much too sophisticated/aware to string along. But even at that, it's not like anyone in the first part of the pilot suspects a real vampire. Prof. Woodard merely tells Sheriff Patterson that there are "unbalanced people" who believe themselves to be vampires - not that they're actual vampires.
Title: Re: Discuss: '91 Series - Pilot - Part 1
Post by: Nelson Collins on September 14, 2008, 04:11:23 AM
My 666th post! [laughing6]

Okay, one of the frustrating things is that there are some characters that I suspect will become more prominent and I have no idea who they are.

Just about everyone else gets a name but who is the doctor that treats Daphne?  Hiram?  Same with the man Sheriff Patterson visits.  Based on what we've seen so far, I don't recall his name being used nor really what the heck Patterson was doing there in the first place.  What is their relationship?  Based on the dialogue, it seems that Patterson goes to this guy when confronted with a case outside the mainstream, which would indicate to me that Collinsport is an occasional hotbed of weird activity.  Yet nowhere else in the episode (prior to Barnabas' appearance) is there any indication that Collinsport is such a place.  If it were, then why does Sam let Daphne walk out of the Blue Whale alone at night without a second thought.  But Patterson goes to see this guy in the house with strange supernatural items all through it?  And thanks him with an "As always, thanks for your help" ?

I'm not intrigued by this yet, merely mildly annoyed that the writing here is a bit sloppy (IMHO, of course.)
Title: Re: Discuss: '91 Series - Pilot - Part 1
Post by: Mysterious Benefactor on September 14, 2008, 04:43:58 AM
Considering that you've already watched the whole pilot, you [spoiler]needn't worry too much about the doctor because you've already seen all you're ever going to see of him. But for the record, his name is Dr. Hiram Fisher. He was supposed to turn up in Ep #4, but his entire part landed up on the cutting room floor. More on that after we get to Ep #4...[/spoiler]

As for the man the sheriff goes to see, I believe the writers were being deliberately mysterious about him. All we explicitly learn from his first scene is that he's a professor. But from the paraphernalia around his house, we can deduce he's probably an anthropologist. And it's not unusual for the police to consult an anthropologist from time to time, particularly in cases involving unusual assailants. But as to the full extent of the relationship, we're left to wonder about that - and that isn't such a bad thing...
Title: Re: Discuss: '91 Series - Pilot - Part 1
Post by: michael c on September 14, 2008, 05:08:29 AM
as i said i was just expressing an opinion...

but i still don't considering building suspense as being "strung along"...

nor do i consider myself to be "unsophisticated/unaware".

and i find the tone of these comments,whether intended or not,to be quite insulting.
Title: Re: Discuss: '91 Series - Pilot - Part 1
Post by: Mysterious Benefactor on September 14, 2008, 05:19:36 AM
I don't think the writers intended their comments to be insulting to their potential audience. Quite the opposite - I believe they were complimenting the audience's intelligence. The basic idea was that practically anyone coming to DS was already all too well aware that they were going to be seeing a vampire story, so what would actually be insulting to the audience would be to try to pretend in any way otherwise. They felt the audience would be too sophisticated and aware enough to spot a vampire story from a mile off when they saw one.
Title: Re: Discuss: '91 Series - Pilot - Part 1
Post by: Midnite on September 14, 2008, 06:46:01 AM
nor do i consider myself to be "unsophisticated/unaware".

Nor does anyone here.  MB is saying that a writing decision was made over what type of fans they wished to appeal to, and that was fans of vampire stories.  This is evident in the NBC promos that are on display, since they seem to stress the horror and vampire angles, which is a pity since the series could have reached an even larger audience had the pre-publicity acknowledged the Gothic romance theme as well, but I digress.

But I really want to make the point that, as in all board discussions about DS, everyone is entitled to their opinion.

midnite...
...
i've lived in california and i've lived in maine.the play of the sunlight and the foliage are totally different.there's not mistaking that this was filmed in california.

OMG, I've never heard of that!  I misunderstood what you meant about the blazing sun, oops.

Since you're watching on DVD, I'm wondering if what you're also seeing is due to their lightening the print during the DVD transfer so that nighttime events appear to take place in bright sunlight; it certainly affects my enjoyment of certain scenes.  Barnabas should not be and was not in the woods at noon.  <sigh>
Title: Re: Discuss: '91 Series - Pilot - Part 1
Post by: Cousin_Barnabas on September 14, 2008, 07:47:35 AM
...indicate to me that Collinsport is an occasional hotbed of weird activity... If it were, then why does Sam let Daphne walk out of the Blue Whale alone at night without a second thought. 

This could be attributed to the fact that it has been awhile since the last "bizarre happening".  (With the inclusion of the word "occasional", you provided part of the solution to your question.)  It is a really common occurrence for people to return to having a false sense of security if something bad hasn't happened recently, but did a few months prior.  (I see it all the time.)  This, of course, is just me explaining away that part of your post, and has really little to do with much else, so pay no attention to the man behind the curtain... er... coffin!   [ghost_cheesy]
Title: Re: Discuss: '91 Series - Pilot - Part 1
Post by: Miss_Winthrop on September 14, 2008, 01:07:35 PM
Thanks for bringing up the Carolyn and Joe thing.  I hadn't even noticed that and it is an interesting angle.   In one scene, an accidental shot of a window with the bright Calif sun shining in must have gotten past the editors...I could sit around and nit pick to death every little miscue and it might be fun to do sometime but my thinking is, a person seeing the show for the first time wouldn't have picked up on the mistakes.  There is a lot going on. Also, I can see a man like Roger who might dearly love his son, become so frustrated by his (David's) behavior, end of thinking that it would have been better off if the mother hadn't succombed to spare the child.  The Willie character is certainly very unusual in that he vascillates back an forth from being the village idiot to this really mean, nasty individual who probably blames everyone else for his misfortunes.  His character seems to go back and forth between those two extremes and I don't feel an ounce of empathy for him.
Title: Re: Discuss: '91 Series - Pilot - Part 1
Post by: michael c on September 14, 2008, 02:10:45 PM
i realize that the audience for this show was obviously going to get the vampire angle from the get-go.

i was refering more to collinsport law enforcement and the townspeople getting wise to it too soon.that's why i was surpried to hear it referenced so quickly.

but frankly i feel rather bullied in this topic so this will be my last post in it.
Title: Re: Discuss: '91 Series - Pilot - Part 1
Post by: LeFanu on September 14, 2008, 04:06:42 PM
oh hey, mscbryk don't go - i know i'm interested in reading your comments.

i thought the pilot got off to a good start. although i can see the seams - the quality of light is wrong and the buildings don't really look right for new england - they did an effective job of creating a creepy, gloomy mood.

i tend to go back and forth on some of the actors. willie is strange, and i don't get what's going on with his teeth. is this "british book of smiles" or something? he's alternately dumb and threatening, but i suspect that's the writing. jim fyfe manages to project some pathos into the role, and i think that's what vicki was reacting to when she agreed to get into the truck with him

it's strange that there's really no mention of victoria's background. what would cause a stunningly beautiful twenty-five-year-old woman of relative sophistication to chuck everything and head out for this small town to be a governess? seems like something out of a nineteenth century novel.

there isn't much going on to let us know who the collins family members are, either. elizabeth seems kind, but so far, the character is just a sketch. and there is no explanation as to why she has an english accent while roger sounds like any well bred man of his generation.

carolyn is just...weird. seems like she's tripping or high all the time. and i have to agree with whoever said upthread that there was even a scene in which it seemed like she wanted to seduce victoria.

they don't waste any time in getting to the vampire, do they? less than fifteen minutes in, and willie has already found his resting place. really liked the rhyme about the lion and the dove. why do you suppose that was written? did someone hope the vampire would eventually be found?

daphne is such a throwaway character. even though i think it is stated that she is a collins, she has "star trek red shirt" written all over her. when she was found after the attack i had to think "wow - that barnabas is a messy eater!" but then again, he must've been hungry after his 200 year fast!

two of the best actors so far (imho) are mrs. johnson and david. both are utterly believable. while it's strange that vicki isn't more put off by the little guy's hostility, it appears she won him over pretty fast. an aside - why are the family letting david play in the old house? wouldn't that be unsafe?

maybe i missed it, but was it ever explicitly stated where this is all taking place? the police car i saw in one scene may have had maine license plates, but i couldn't tell for sure.

it's odd to me that the collins family would just accept barnabas being who he claims to be at face value. i'd think they might run a background check on him - even given that he looks so like the portrait of his "ancestor." and did anyone notice the other portrait on the stairway next to his? it looked like marlon brando in "the godfather"!

really loved the look barnabas gave vicki when he first saw her - despite his restraint, it's clear that there is something more going on than him being bowled over by her beauty. and joanna going played her first encounter with the vampire just right: a hesitation/attraction combination mostly shown in her eyes and through body language.

can't wait for next week!

Title: Re: Discuss: '91 Series - Pilot - Part 1
Post by: Nelson Collins on September 14, 2008, 04:15:20 PM
and i find the tone of these comments,whether intended or not,to be quite insulting.
I for one apologize for the harshness of my comment about tax fraud.  No disdain or insult was intended.  I simply did not see how you could read tax fraud into the playful banter of that scene, but even though you yourself dismissed the comment later, you put it out there.  It's only fair that others will remark on it.  (TBH, I'm surprised no one has blasted me for suggesting that Carolyn was trying to seduce Vicki ....  [ghost_wink] )

I agree with your observation that the building of suspense was perhaps compromised by introducing the idea of a vampire so early in the narrative.  I generally think that in places the writing of the pilot (though credited to I think four writer's, including DC) has DCs fingerprints all over it, and shows DC's willingness to sacrifice character and exposition and suspense, to "hurry up and get his vampire freak on."

Having said that, I'm okay with that to a certain extent.  Like my earlier comments about Willie, I like that Patterson and co. aren't defaulting to the most likely scenario and thinking outside the box.  At this point, their thinking outside the box amounts to a madman who thinks he's a vampire (because we all know real vampires don't exist).

[spoiler]Patterson also won more respect from me in an episode down the road, when he reveals that Barnabas has been his prime suspect pretty much all along, but that's for another week ....[/spoiler]

I hope that you will reconsider, and will be joining us for the rest of the project.  [ghost_smiley]
Title: Re: Discuss: '91 Series - Pilot - Part 1
Post by: Mysterious Benefactor on September 14, 2008, 05:03:17 PM
Since you're watching on DVD, I'm wondering if what you're also seeing is due to their lightening the print during the DVD transfer so that nighttime events appear to take place in bright sunlight; it certainly affects my enjoyment of certain scenes.  Barnabas should not be and was not in the woods at noon.  <sigh>

Even though there are several topics that go into the horrors of how the DVD release was terribly botched by Sony, it can probably never be mentioned enough that anyone being exposed to the '91 series for the first time by watching it on DVD isn't getting the same experience as having watched it originally or on MPI's VHS release. For example, here's a side by side comparison of just a few moments from Daphne's walk to her car:

Original with filtering:
DVD with filtering mistakenly "corrected":
(http://www.dsboards.com/dvdvhs/org-1.jpg)(http://www.dsboards.com/dvdvhs/dvd-1.jpg)
(http://www.dsboards.com/dvdvhs/org-2.jpg)(http://www.dsboards.com/dvdvhs/dvd-2.jpg)
(http://www.dsboards.com/dvdvhs/org-3.jpg)(http://www.dsboards.com/dvdvhs/dvd-3.jpg)

Title: Re: Discuss: '91 Series - Pilot - Part 1
Post by: LeFanu on September 14, 2008, 05:15:31 PM
wow, that's a huge difference! thanks for posting those, mb.

a friend of mine taped the show on vhs during the original run. will be seeing him next weekend. perhaps we can watch an episode or two. i figured it couldn't just be that i remembered it looking more eerie the first time i saw it.

what can those idiots have been thinking in "cleaning" up the picture? destroys half of the creep factor.
Title: Re: Discuss: '91 Series - Pilot - Part 1
Post by: Nelson Collins on September 14, 2008, 05:54:22 PM
What was the deal "letterboxing" it.  Did Sony see all the boom mikes that drifted into shot and assumed that they were meant to be "removed" by the black bars?

BTW, is anyone keeping an eye out for said boom mikes?
Title: Re: Discuss: '91 Series - Pilot - Part 1
Post by: Midnite on September 14, 2008, 09:33:11 PM
Actually, that entire sequence was shot outdoors on the Columbia Ranch.  [ghost_smiley]

I think it was on the WB studio lot.  This was taken from the VIP tour tram, so sorry it's not the greatest, but I'm 98% sure it's the same house in MB's screen grabs (p. 3).

I have no idea where the building is that was used as the Blue Whale.  I do, however, know exactly where its neon sign is.  ;)
Title: Re: Discuss: '91 Series - Pilot - Part 1
Post by: Mysterious Benefactor on September 14, 2008, 09:56:26 PM
I think it was on the WB studio lot.

Now they're one and the same, but it was once owned by Columbia. Check out: 1164 Morning Glory Circle: Warner Bros. Ranch (http://www.1164.com/ranch/index.html)

Quote
This was taken from the VIP tour tram, so sorry it's not the greatest, but I'm 98% sure it's the same house in MB's screen grabs (p. 3).

How wild that you've been there.  [ghost_wink]

Quote
I have no idea where the building is that was used as the Blue Whale.

The exterior is also on the WB Burbank backlot - somewhere. However, Tin Horn Flats, also in Burbank, was used for the interior in the pilot. 

Quote
I do, however, know exactly where its neon sign is.  ;)

And I wonder where that is?  [b003]
Title: Re: Discuss: '91 Series - Pilot - Part 1
Post by: arashi on September 14, 2008, 09:57:29 PM
Daphne I always assumed was from another branch of the family, a second cousin or something. Given how large Collinwood is, and how the family's seat of power rests in the town, I think it's easy to believe the extended family would have lived in the house until around the turn of the century, and then still live in the area.

I wish I had my VHS tapes here, and am going to have to figure out how to rip the tapes to my computer, because I really miss the "missing scenes". The scene where Vicki sees Barnabas out the window always struck my as genuinely creepy. The color correction really is something of a bother. I hope at sometime in the future MPI does a proper release of the series.

Joanna Going really is quite striking. She's beautiful, but still very innocent looking. I think they cast her quite well. (interestingly enough, she was raised in Newport, Rhode Island, so she must have been very aware of a certain semi-famous mansion in town). I wish they had elaborated on her past though, because really, unless the Collins family was offering her a substantial amount of money, what reasons would she have for going there?

I'll raise my hand and say that I too was always bothered by Roger sending Willie, drunk and slovenly, to pick up Vicki at the train station in a beat up pick up truck. Though, I took it that Roger wasn't too keen on having Vicki there in the first place, so he might not have cared to roll out the red carpet for her. It'll be fun to speculate about Roger's wife in the future - but at this point we know that she went crazy because of David and a fire.... which still isn't really telling us much.

David is a little monster. He's probably extremely lonely, if he's "been without his Father" for six years, where was Roger? Did he dump him off at Collinwood? Carolyn strikes me as pretty lonely as well. She probably revels in the thought of another woman around her age coming to the estate - and someone whose whole world isn't the town of Collinsport and it's surrounding area.

Ben Cross - I'm still kind of torn about. He just kind of sticks out to me, which could be a good thing, because his character hardly blends in with the locals so to speak.
Title: Re: Discuss: '91 Series - Pilot - Part 1
Post by: Gerard on September 14, 2008, 10:21:56 PM
David is a little monster. He's probably extremely lonely, if he's "been without his Father" for six years, where was Roger? Did he dump him off at Collinwood?

Wasn't David living with his mother, Laura, in England?  I thought Liz went to get him and bring him back to Collinwood, but not sure here.

Gerard
Title: Re: Discuss: '91 Series - Pilot - Part 1
Post by: Mysterious Benefactor on September 14, 2008, 10:28:05 PM
I generally think that in places the writing of the pilot (though credited to I think four writer's, including DC) has DCs fingerprints all over it, and shows DC's willingness to sacrifice character and exposition and suspense, to "hurry up and get his vampire freak on."

That's very perceptive of you. And according to Sam and Matt Hall, the series' writing team was split with DC and Steve Feke (the other writer for the pilot and the series' Supervising Producer) being all for emphasizing the the blood and gore and horror, whereas Matt, Linda Campanelli and Shelly Moore wanted the romantic elements to predominate. The contrast between the mini-series eps and the Friday eps (for lack of a better distinction) can be stark at times. Personally, while I steadfastly believe blood, gore and horror definitely have a place in vampire stories - and I particularly enjoy them in Hammer films - I prefer the Hall, Campanelli and Moore approach to the Curtis and Feke approach when it comes to DS.

Incidentally, Hall Powell and Bill Taub's only job was condensing storyline from existing DS source material. They added absolutely no new storyline ideas of their own - and they only worked on the mini-series eps.

David is a little monster. He's probably extremely lonely, if he's "been without his Father" for six years, where was Roger? Did he dump him off at Collinwood?

Wasn't David living with his mother, Laura, in England?  I thought Liz went to get him and bring him back to Collinwood, but not sure here.

During the restored scene when Vicki questions Elizabeth about David and Vicki asks how long David has been without his father, Elizabeth replies for almost six years and that she went to England and brought David back to Collinwood shortly after his mother "took ill." However, according the concordance for the '91 series, the part about asking about David's father was a mistake in the script that didn't get corrected before it was shot. Vicki was supposed to have asked how long David had been without his mother. The writers were actually happy that that goof had been cut from the mini-series.

It's been so long since I've watched the '91 series that I don't recall all the other bits of background we'll be getting concerning David and his parents - but it will be interesting to discover them again...
Title: Re: Discuss: '91 Series - Pilot - Part 1
Post by: Gerard on September 14, 2008, 11:24:41 PM
That's where I remember hearing about it, MB!  (Meaning David in England and all that.)  I thought I was suffering that bout of FDSMS (Faulty Dark Shadows Memory Syndrome) again.  Now, here's another FDSMS question:  when '91 was re-aired (a few times, I think) on the Sci-Fi Channel, was it with the restored scenes or not?  I keep thinking I saw them there, or was it just because I read about them in the Resurrected book and my left brain crossed with my right brain?

Gerard
Title: Re: Discuss: '91 Series - Pilot - Part 1
Post by: Midnite on September 15, 2008, 01:44:02 AM
Now they're one and the same, but it was once owned by Columbia. Check out:

Thanks, point taken.  :)  The ranch and larger studio are separate facilities, though; that page says they're a mile apart and I think it's closer to a half mile, but they're on opposite sides of the Ventura Fwy.  Anyway, the Studio has frequent public tours that include a visit to the WB Museum (a must for Harry Potter fans), but the Ranch only has private tours and photography is prohibited.

Quote
The exterior is also on the WB Burbank backlot - somewhere. However, Tin Horn Flats, also in Burbank, was used for the interior in the pilot.

Thanks again!  I didn't know that.  :D
Title: Re: Discuss: '91 Series - Pilot - Part 1
Post by: Taeylor Collins on September 15, 2008, 05:26:15 AM
and i find the tone of these comments,whether intended or not,to be quite insulting.
I for one apologize for the harshness of my comment about tax fraud.  No disdain or insult was intended.  I simply did not see how you could read tax fraud into the playful banter of that scene, but even though you yourself dismissed the comment later, you put it out there.  It's only fair that others will remark on it.  (TBH, I'm surprised no one has blasted me for suggesting that Carolyn was trying to seduce Vicki ....  [ghost_wink] )

Hey guys I have been feeling rough so I haven't really been able to sit long enough to type out my review! Hopefully I will tomorrow.  I wanted to comment on your comment Nelson.  I actually read (and maybe someone can back this up) that Barbara Blackburn played her first scene with Victoria very flirtatiously!!  [ghost_shocked] I think it would be par for the course though for a 90's Carolyn!!  However if her and Victoria [spoiler]turned out to be sisters that would have been very ICKY![/spoiler]

Hope to post more tomorrow!

Night cousins!

MSCBRYK please don't leave.  I for one meant no harm or malice when I questioned your statement about tax fraud.  I was just commenting on your comments.  You are entitled to your opinion and I just read over my post and didn't feel it bullied anyone.  I extend my deepest regret if you felt this way.  Try to remember emotions are hard to convey over a machine.  It's even pointed out by our lovely mods in the Rules for the boards. [ghost_wink]
Title: Re: Discuss: '91 Series - Pilot - Part 1
Post by: Philippe Cordier on September 15, 2008, 06:35:47 AM
I rewatched "Scene 5" last night and thought it was well done ... but now I can't remember anything about it!  Except, does anyone else think it strange that Barnabas' coffin is so exposed?  Anyone walking down the basement stairs would easily see it, and why is it on some sort of pedestal?  You'd think it would have been hidden a little more out of sight.

Great line (though unfortunately I'm forgetting the entire line):  Mrs. Johnson:  "Barnabas Collins must be a wonderful man."

Title: Re: Discuss: '91 Series - Pilot - Part 1
Post by: michael c on September 16, 2008, 12:12:55 AM
it wasn't so much the 'tax fraud' comments...that i probably deserved...that prompted me to opt out of this particular discussion.

but more other points that were repeatedly corrected/contradicted that i had grown weary of having to justify.this is supposed to be fun.

but no matter.there's always next weeks' discussion.
Title: Re: Discuss: '91 Series - Pilot - Part 1
Post by: Mysterious Benefactor on September 16, 2008, 01:14:36 PM
Continuing in the forum's long standing belief that it's always fun to learn behind the scenes/production tidbits, thinking and facts, and given that the way some of the characters have been dressed has been discussed a bit in this topic, I figured it might be interesting to share some of Rosalie Samplin Wallace's thoughts (anything between [] are my comments) that I recently rediscovered:

From the '91 series' concordance:
Costume designer Rosalie Wallace described how they came up with Barnabas' look: "We've tried to romanticize him by giving him a soft, fluid line." She used sensual silks and cottons in dark olive, maroon and navy blue for his shirts. His charcoal-grey fine wool pants had double pleats. For indoors, he wore a paisley quilted smoking jacket in gray and black velvet, or a long quilted velvet bathrobe in navy. [Well, what would Barnabas be without a smoking jacket?!  [lghy]  [wink2]]
The women in Collinsport wore a variety of styles. Victoria wore romantic soft crocheted sweaters and lacy feminine blouses. Julia wore severe straight skirts and jackets. For Carolyn's "a little trash, with class" Rosalie chose skirts that "are too tight and too short. Her sweaters are cut too low." And "Elizabeth favors silk blouses, sweaters, soft dark blazers and fine wool pants. [Apparently she and Barnabas share a similar taste in pants.  ;)]
Wallace "buys for look and not for the label." Barnabas wears multipleated pants from Giorgio Armani and an occasional Ralph Lauren jacket. Dr. Hoffman wears Ralph Lauren skirts and Joan Vass sweaters and shirts. Victoria is seen in a Kanji organza skirt and top.
Wallace frequented Neiman Matrcus, Bullocks, Nordstrom and I. Magnin. Some of Joanna's costumes came from Kanji on Melrose, and a lot of Jean Simmons' wardrobe was bought at Ron Ross in Encino.
Title: Re: Discuss: '91 Series - Pilot - Part 1
Post by: Cassandra Blair on September 16, 2008, 06:37:34 PM
Sorry I'm late to the party - just didn't have time to watch the pilot (or is it mini-series?) until yesterday afternoon. Then I made the mistake of watching the whole thing, instead of just the first hour. Guess I'm caught up for next week, right?

Anyway, I so enjoyed seeing this again. Yes, it's true that things are a bit rushed, and there isn't much character development thus far, but they've definitely established a feeling of foreboding that I think works. And I don't mind that they just jump right into the supernatural. I get the feeling maybe some things have already happened in town that make people say "hmmmm..."

One thing I couldn't figure out is what season of the year is all of this supposed to be happening? There's a scene in which Vicki is wearing a heavy coat and gloves, I think. Yet the trees have green leaves on them. Kind of an oversight in my book, but not as glaring as the obvious 'day-for-night' shots near the end of the episode.

[spoiler]I loved the scene which takes place at the roadhouse or whatever it was; Carolyn's out doing a slutty dance with whoever, and that cheesily-dressed female who becomes Barnabas's next victim says to him in the parking lot: "Where are you from? You talk kinda funny." Doesn't the woman know not to trust a dude in a cape?[/spoiler]

And why is Barnabas's accent so definitively English? I don't know how the 'quality' in America spoke in the late 18th century, so maybe that's just me.

My other question is would they really have had the capability to bring Collinwood over from England brick by brick so long ago? But I did love the speech Barnabas gave about how it happened. I think Ben Cross was a really decent choice for the part, he's got a manner about him that is certainly otherworldly.

(edited by admin)
Title: Re: Discuss: '91 Series - Pilot - Part 1
Post by: Nelson Collins on September 16, 2008, 07:59:44 PM
Has anyone else ever noted or commented on the irony of an actor named "Cross" being cast as a vampire?   [ghost_tongue2]
Title: Re: Discuss: '91 Series - Pilot - Part 1
Post by: Nelson Collins on September 16, 2008, 08:09:55 PM
Re: accents - Liz sounds extremely English as well, which is rather odd, since absolutely no one else in the family (that was born in the 20th century, that is [ghost_wink]) sounds English at all.

I have a friend who grew up in rural Arkansas with an Arkansan father and a Cockney mother and his accent was the strangest mix I have ever heard from a US born American!

So, I suppose at some point after Carolyn learned to talk, Liz decided to put on a few airs!   [ghost_grin]
Title: Re: Discuss: '91 Series - Pilot - Part 1
Post by: Gerard on September 17, 2008, 12:14:51 AM
The whole question of Liz's accent reminds me of the episode of Roseanne where Joan Collins plays her cousin.  They get into an argument and Roseanne says (paraphrasing here):  "And where do you come off with that hoidy-toidy accent?  You grew up in Illinois!"

Gerard
Title: Re: Discuss: '91 Series - Pilot - Part 1
Post by: Nelson Collins on September 17, 2008, 12:27:52 AM
[Mame]Well, when you're from Illinois, you have to do something.[/Mame]
Title: Re: Discuss: '91 Series - Pilot - Part 1
Post by: Cousin_Barnabas on September 17, 2008, 01:25:20 AM
I was always under the impression that Elizabeth was schooled in England, and that was the reason Jean kept her accent for the character.
Title: Re: Discuss: '91 Series - Pilot - Part 1
Post by: Zahir on September 17, 2008, 03:15:47 AM
...does anyone else think it strange that Barnabas' coffin is so exposed?  Anyone walking down the basement stairs would easily see it, and why is it on some sort of pedestal?  You'd think it would have been hidden a little more out of sight...
If it were me, that coffin would be behind several locked doors, hidden behind furniture and most certainly covered with a tarp or something.  Plus it wouldn't be exposed to the sunlight!

Unless Barnabas has some kind of deathwish, which seems possible.
Title: Re: Discuss: '91 Series - Pilot - Part 1
Post by: Nelson Collins on September 17, 2008, 03:35:05 AM
A gentle reminder - [spoiler]Barn's stylishly overexposed coffin and Carolyn's slutty dancing at the Blue Whale are in the 2nd half of the pilot...  [ghost_wink][/spoiler]

I suppose Liz could have been schooled in England.  England does seem to play a part in the extended version of the pilot part 1 (Liz going to England to get David, for example) but unless she was practically born and reared there (which also is possible) and her parents spoke with English accents, (which is moving us into increasing improbability since neither Roger nor David have any hint of an accent) I'd say it's far more likely the accent is an affectation, which really just doesn't seem, well, Liz, if you know what I mean.

Speaking of improbability, as often as the modern Collinses seem to have spent time in England, it starts to get even more odd (or sloppy) that they they knew nothing of an English branch of the family and therefore it makes Barnabas' story even flimsier.
Title: Re: Discuss: '91 Series - Pilot - Part 1
Post by: Gerard on September 17, 2008, 03:42:53 AM
That's one of my problems.  While evoking "atmosphere" is of a good deal of importance, so is a certain sense of "reality."  A coffin containing a vampire who's on a most-wanted list certainly looks nice being the centerpiece of a cruise ship midnight buffet display, but - honestly - if the vampire is trying to be, shall we say, discreet, one would think he would prefer having his resting chamber buried and hidden under boxes of saved Coolwhip bowls and Christmas decorations, blending in with the don't-throw-it-out-because-you'll-never-know-when-you'll-need-to-use-it bricabrac found in everyone's basement.

Gerard
Title: Re: Discuss: '91 Series - Pilot - Part 1
Post by: Midnite on September 17, 2008, 04:20:02 AM
Has anyone else ever noted or commented on the irony of an actor named "Cross" being cast as a vampire?   [ghost_tongue2]

My friend Kosmo reminded me about the 1990 TV Guide article with the title, "This time Cross resurrects vampire."

 [ghost_cheesy]
Title: Re: Discuss: '91 Series - Pilot - Part 1
Post by: Midnite on September 17, 2008, 04:42:05 AM
I rewatched "Scene 5" last night and thought it was well done ... but now I can't remember anything about it!  Except, does anyone else think it strange that Barnabas' coffin is so exposed?  Anyone walking down the basement stairs would easily see it, and why is it on some sort of pedestal?  You'd think it would have been hidden a little more out of sight.

If you meant Chapter 5, could you please hold that thought until next week's discussion?  This week's episode completes the DVD's Chapter 4.

One thing I couldn't figure out is what season of the year is all of this supposed to be happening? There's a scene in which Vicki is wearing a heavy coat and gloves, I think. Yet the trees have green leaves on them. Kind of an oversight in my book, but not as glaring as the obvious 'day-for-night' shots near the end of the episode.

And please feel free to bring this up again during next week's discussion.  ;)
Title: Re: Discuss: '91 Series - Pilot - Part 1
Post by: Miss_Winthrop on September 17, 2008, 12:46:56 PM
I recall an old Hitchcock movie called 'The Rope' where the newly departed was kept in a buffet while the party guests were served food from it's closed top.  Of course the exposed coffin of Barnabas would have had a different affect if it had been kept in the dining room.
Title: Re: Discuss: '91 Series - Pilot - Part 1
Post by: KMR on September 17, 2008, 07:47:45 PM
but - honestly - if the vampire is trying to be, shall we say, discreet, one would think he would prefer having his resting chamber buried and hidden under boxes of saved Coolwhip bowls and Christmas decorations, blending in with the don't-throw-it-out-because-you'll-never-know-when-you'll-need-to-use-it bricabrac found in everyone's basement.

HA!!  I can see it now.  Barnabas is rummaging through the cellar, throwing the Cool Whip bowls and tinsel garland around, muttering "I know I put that coffin down here SOMEWHERE!"
Title: Re: Discuss: '91 Series - Pilot - Part 1
Post by: Gothick on September 17, 2008, 09:13:00 PM
I just loved MB's comments about the clothes.  The idea of Liz wearing Bea Arthur's wardrobe from the Golden Girls is a hoot.  I really hated how they dressed Jean Simmons in that role.

Maybe Victoria's extra shoulder pads were a case of proactive defense against psychotic children of rich, isolated New England families?

G.
Title: Re: Discuss: '91 Series - Pilot - Part 1
Post by: Taeylor Collins on September 18, 2008, 01:55:31 AM
Pilot Pt. 1 VO: Joanna Going Air: Jan. 13 1991

Hey guys.  I wrote two pages (front and page) and am gonna try and condense as much as I can.  I get really nostalgic watching DS '91 because like the original fans feel about Dark Shadows, I feel the same way about this version.  It was my foray into the world of Dark Shadows and I was hooked from the first 5 minutes.  I think in many ways in changed the course of my life and was a key factor in my coming out.  Isn't it amazing how art can make such a mark on our lives??  Onto the review!

I absolutely love how Dark Shadows opens.  It have a very cinematic feel to it.  I for one am glad they opted to treat this like a movie by not having a traditional opening credits.  I love how the camera pans down towards the train with the sun in low in sky.  I also love the beautiful rays that bounce off the camera and cause that really neat looking ball of light.  It makes for an amazing effect.  Right off I am drawn into this mysterious world as the gorgeous Victoria Winters introduces herself and like her we enter into the world of Dark Shadows.  We also are quickly introduced to Carloyn (complete with a leather '90's miniskirt) and a very 'cocky' attitude.  We also met Mrs. Johnson, Elizabeth, and Daphne Collins.  I too like many others always wondered how Daphne was related to the family??   I think Jean Simmons is a beautiful woman and I love her beautiful rich, thick English accent.  I too wonder if she was reared in ENGLAND as Roger doesn't have the accent.  I suspect if the show had continued we may have been privy to that information.

We see the camera pan down from a sign that says "COLLINSPORT" and to me this is when the score really begins to amp up.  I am immediately drawn deeper into the show by the music.  Side Note: My first visual encounter with DS was this show. However, I used to listen to my mother's DS record she had left at my Grandmother's house.  There was nothing but the record (no sleeve) left but the music was very scary and haunting to me.  SO in a way I have to thank the original DS record for bringing DS to my attention.  Once I saw the promos in TV GUIDE for DS '91 I set out to watch. My Joanna Going is one lovely woman and I think  there was no other actress who could have played Victoria '91.  Or maybe I am just parcel?? LOL

I noticed as Mrs. J tries to call Willie we see there are phone lines going "OUT" to the "School Room" "Gate" "Drawing Room" "Green House" and "Stable"  My Collinwood is a vast estate indeed.  The Drawing Room, The Foyer, and Grand Staircase are my favorite sets on the show.  They are beautifully built, wonderfully decorated, and just BEYOND GRAND!!!

I notice that Willie is reading THE BOOK OF THE DEAD.  Is this a fictional or real book? 

Right off I really really like Maggie.  I think Ely Pouget was an wonderful choice and I wish she had gotten more work over the years.  I was so pleased to see her in an episode of Season 7 of Charmed.  By the way MB you said at one time that Ely Pouget wasn't going to be in the show as much but the producers liked her so much they included more.  Was Maggie just gonna be a kind of side character??

I for one was outright aggravated that Carolyn called Victoria "Vickie"!  UGHHH!!  First of all I thought that was rather rude.  She could have said, "May I call you Vickie"  I thought it was quite presumptuous on her part.  Plus if anyone ever notices in my post I never refer to Victoria as Vickie because I feel that when you reduce Victoria to Vickie it ruins a EXQUSITE name to a common sounding name!  I have always said if I am blessed with a daughter one day I will call her Victoria and defy anyone to call her Vickie and she will grow up knowing she isn't to be called Vickie!!  No offense to anyone out there that uses Vickie.  I just find Victoria more regal and if I remember correctly Barnabas '91 never calls her Vickie.  Which I think is perfect.  I cannot see a 18Th century man calling Victoria, Vickie!  Sorry for the [Rant_Emote]!!

Great high shot of the Victoria, Carolyn, and Elizabeth as they excite the Foyer.  A storm is brewing which is never a good sign.  As Willie goes back and for between the lion and the dove there is a great LOW shot of a tomb that has COLLINS emblazoned on the side of it.  Wonder which ancestor is interned in it? The possibilities were endless....:(  I kinda of wonder how bats got into the secret room and how they survived?? 

The staircase is my favorite. Now that is a GRAND STAIRCASE!!  I wonder who the man is in the other portrait on the landing??  I also like the fact that no one really knows how many rooms there are in the house.  Very cool.  I think that was a great way to go as it opens up a lot more possibilities.

Joseph Gordon Levitt is a great little actor and I knew he would go very very far one day.  I suggest Latter Days. If you are a gay man it will pull at your heartstrings and if you are gay friendly it will too.  I also suggest his movie he did  with Greg Araki called Mysterious Skin.

I suspect Barnabas really made a lot of money from those old jewels.  I suspect this is where he attains his monies from at least for a while. I guess he could also invest in business ventures as long as he could conduct his work at night.

I absolutely love the shot of Barnabas walking towards Collinwood. Beautifully shot with all the elements in place. I also love when Barnabas gazes all around the Foyer and sees endless portraits hanging on the wall.  GOOD LORD what high ceilings!!

I love the scene with Barnabas, Carolyn, Elizabeth and Roger. I also love the fact that the "ORIGINAL" Barnabas helped to elect John Adams "...along with Thomas Jefferson as his Vice President"  I am gonna forgive their error because this is the world of Dark Shadows and they can make their own rules.  I swear Carolyn looks as if she is sizing up her own cousin! LOL She is so slinky!!  Also I read it here or some reviewer commented that Ben Cross was too tan to play Barnabas. However, I disagree.  He had fed on Willie and drained poor ole Daphne almost to death hence the color back in his skin.  If you will notice later on in the series, [spoiler]he is very pale before going to bite other victims.[/spoiler] My favorite scene of this first part is Barnabas telling the story of how Collinwood was assembled.  He told it with such conviction and verve. I believed every word and it was a wonderfully written monologue perfectly executeted by Ben Cross.  "Money is of no consequence" Barnabas tells his cousins as he says he wants to restore the Old House.  I think to myself.  IT MUST BE NICE!!!  [ghost_wink] "I can't believe it!  Our family's first home in America come back to life" Elizabeth  "Yeeeeeeeeeeees"  Barnabas  I absolutely loved how Ben Cross delivered that line.  As David comes into the room he seem to almost be in a trance.  GREAT closeup on Ben Cross as he looks upon Sarah's portrait.  He has nice lips!  [happy7]

I love the closing scenes of Barnabas making his way toward The Old House.  Great cinematography.  I love the final shot as he says, "Father!  I have come home" 

B+  Only because I think this episode did a good job of laying the groundwork however I think it could have been improved in some areas. For example: A drunken Willie driving Victoria and the rushed plot.  And also because I think better installments are to come which will warrant a higher score.

I again want to extend my thanks to our WONDERFUL mods for granting my wish, my hats off to you both!!  [wavey]  I look forward to reliving this glorious series in the next few months!
Title: Re: Discuss: '91 Series - Pilot - Part 1
Post by: Midnite on September 18, 2008, 04:49:48 AM
Taeylor, I was so happy to read that you're feeling better!

My Joanna Going is one lovely woman and I think  there was no other actress who could have played Victoria '91.  Or maybe I am just parcel?? LOL

I think she was a perfect Victoria too, and I was shocked to learn that she almost didn't make it past her early audition.  Apparently we have Dan Curtis to thank for realizing the mistake.  Go figure.

It's interesting that you like the detail that the Collinses don't know how many rooms are in their family home.  That bugged me a little.  Yes, it's huge, but it's no Buckingham Palace... and we do know how many rooms that has.

Quote
"I can't believe it!  Our family's first home in America come back to life" Elizabeth  "Yeeeeeeeeeeees"  Barnabas  I absolutely loved how Ben Cross delivered that line.

Me too!  My favorite line so far has to be, "(Barnabas:) My business has always been rather consuming."  Ha ha!

And Willie trying to impress Roger by telling him that instead of working he was spending the time reading, starting with the old books-- too funny.  (Yes, the [Egyptian] Book of the Dead is a real collection of ancient texts.)

Willie can read??!!

Thank you for taking the time to rewrite your review, cuz I know you said you'd lost the first one.  And many thanks for the kind words.
Title: Re: Discuss: '91 Series - Pilot - Part 1
Post by: Philippe Cordier on September 18, 2008, 05:06:53 AM
If you meant Chapter 5, could you please hold that thought until next week's discussion?  This week's episode completes the DVD's Chapter 4.

Oops, sorry about that - I'd forgotten that a viewing schedule was posted giving these guidelines ... I don't have printer capabilities at the moment, otherwise I would have printed it out to refer to.

About Elizabeth's accent ... perhaps Jean Simmons hasn't completely shed her own accent and this may be her own normal way of speaking.  No doubt she could do some kind of "American" accent, but it was probably decided that this "fit" the character because of her cosmopolitanism, education, etc.  Ben Cross's accent serves him well since Barnabas supposedly spent time in England.  But since he actually hadn't gone to England, then he must have decided to do his best approximation of an accent, which just happens to be indistinguishable from that of a native Britisher.

I agree, I always felt that Carolyn was presumptuous in calling Victoria "Vicki" before she even met her.  Like you, I have nearly always referred to "Elizabeth" and "Victoria" in my posts in the past; it seems more respectful.

I noticed Ben Cross's tan (or dark makeup) as well, and would have preferred a pasty vampire look in his early days out the tomb after 200 years.

Good going with the "Cross" comment, I hadn't thought of that.
Title: Re: Discuss: '91 Series - Pilot - Part 1
Post by: Nelson Collins on September 18, 2008, 01:12:37 PM
the Collinses don't know how many rooms are in their family home. 
Carolyn: I'll have my staff get back to you on that....
 [ghost_tongue2]
Title: Re: Discuss: '91 Series - Pilot - Part 1
Post by: Lydia on September 18, 2008, 02:44:08 PM
In my own family, I can easily see the "how many rooms?" question turning into a heated argument as to whether the walk-in closets counted, and whether the three parlors that can be turned into one huge drawing room if you open enough doors should be counted as one room or three.  ("Great-grandmother Collins never closed the doors!"  "But Great-great-great-grandmother Collins always kept them closed because of the draft from the secret panel!")

Until I read mscbryk's comment about Daphne's work at The Blue Whale, it hadn't occurred to me that Daphne's work might be a door left open for a non-supernatural subplot: with Daphne in the hospital, who's going to keep the books for Sam?  I would say that it's unlikely that this series is going to resort to the non-supernatural (heaven forbid!) - but so far David's behavior seems to be non-supernaturally bad.  That reminds me, I'm not sure I'm on the same page with Victoria Winters on how to respond to David.  She's all for "David, I'm here to be your friend!"  As for me, I'd be saying, "David, if you can't learn to behave, you'll be wishing your father had sent you to military school!"

By the way, are there any plans to put up screen captures for captions or setups?
Title: Re: Discuss: '91 Series - Pilot - Part 1
Post by: Taeylor Collins on September 18, 2008, 07:06:04 PM
Thanks to everyone for there comments on my post.  I was so glad to finally be able to be back here on the boards. I really miss them when I am away.  Here are some more screencaps from the first part.  Since Tomorrow we watch the second half I am gonna post the rest I have.
Title: Re: Discuss: '91 Series - Pilot - Part 1
Post by: Taeylor Collins on September 18, 2008, 07:14:23 PM
Here are some more!  Hope it was okay to double post! I love the Woodard picture!  He is making that funny face he always made! However, Stefan Gierasch is MARVELOUS actor in my opinion!!
Title: Re: Discuss: '91 Series - Pilot - Part 1
Post by: Taeylor Collins on September 20, 2008, 01:25:51 AM
Aren't we supposed to have a new thread today for the second part of the PILOT??  I have looked for the orignal annoucment because I thought we may be skipping this Friday.  Anyone??
Title: Re: Discuss: '91 Series - Pilot - Part 1
Post by: Mysterious Benefactor on September 20, 2008, 01:30:56 AM
You've started looking too early.  [ghost_wink]
Title: Re: Discuss: '91 Series - Pilot - Part 1
Post by: Taeylor Collins on September 20, 2008, 01:53:46 AM
Okay.  LOL.  I need to find that Annoucment and review the rules and such. 
Title: Re: Discuss: '91 Series - Pilot - Part 1
Post by: Lydia on September 20, 2008, 02:57:56 PM
I'm figuring the rule in this case is: "MB gets to it when he gets to it."

Changing the subject...I've had the case for the '91 series DVDs lying around near my TV since last week, and every time I look at it, I think: "George Washington!"
Title: Re: Discuss: '91 Series - Pilot - Part 1
Post by: Midnite on September 20, 2008, 03:43:45 PM
I'm figuring the rule in this case is: "MB gets to it when he gets to it."

Actually, he did say this about when the topics would be started:
The topic to discuss the first half of the pilot will be on this board, it will be clearly identified, and it will be started tomorrow night.  [ghost_smiley]
Title: Re: Discuss: '91 Series - Pilot - Part 1
Post by: Nelson Collins on September 20, 2008, 04:04:16 PM
Regarding the portrait next to Barnabas others have asked about, is it Joshua?
Title: Re: Discuss: '91 Series - Pilot - Part 1
Post by: Mysterious Benefactor on September 28, 2008, 10:10:15 PM
(I finally got a chance to write up my notes from the first three installments.)

I like the little hints that are dropped about David's background and his mother. I particularly love the scene between Roger and Elizabeth and the ominous remark that David did something so horrendous that he will never be let back into the local school.

Say what you will, but I love the use of the smoke - especially in the outdoor scenes. Overall I think the cinematography is wonderful and adds such atmosphere. It's a shame that so much of it is ruined on the DVD set (which is why I'm watching my MPI VHS tapes instead).

I love the Collinwood set. It's easy to see why the series cost over $15 million to produce because much of it is on display on screen. The detail of the production design is incredible.

It's probably worth noting again that Maggie and Sam were only supposed to appear in the pilot and never be seen again. But when TPTB saw Ely Pouget on screen they instantly decided that they had to develop the Maggie character to make her a part of the series - and Eddie Jones was lucky enough to get to go along on the ride as Sam.

I really like how Vicki has a perception about people. She could easily see that Willie was an outcast, and apparently feeling sympathy for him rather than being turned off by his behavior at the Blue Whale she agreed to go along with him to Collinwood rather than accept Joe's offer to drive her. I also like how, after Vicki admitted that art was her favorite subject to teach and Roger cynically remarked that he supposed that art was how she got to know children, Vicki comes back with how their art actually helps children to get to know themselves, showing Roger there is more to her than he gave credit at first. It's a real shame that scene was cut from the NBC broadcast.  >:(

I love Barbara Blackburn as Carolyn. I was familiar with her work from when she played Siobhan Ryan on Ryan's Hope and I enjoyed her then - but her Carolyn is on a whole different level - if not on a whole different planet. It's more than a shame that some of her best moments were cut from the NBC broadcast. But then, as we all know, DC's sad motto is "when cuts need to be made, jettison character moments because, hell, who needs them?"  ::)

Another telling remark of Roger's (and naturally, one that was cut from the NBC broadcast): how he never expects anything - that way he's never disappointed. I suspect that has a lot to do with how his marriage has played out. But we'll get a few more clues about that down the line...

I definitely like how the great hall at Collinwood seemingly has dozens of portraits on display. They could have been the perfect set up to introduce a whole slew of ancestors/characters. But alas...

I love the look on Barnabas' face after the one-two punch of seeing Vicki and hearing about Sarah. His remark about possibly upsetting David is far more meaningful when one considers it from the POV that it's actually Barnabas himself who's far more upset but summoning all his power to cover it.

I never noticed before this viewing, but I find it quite interesting that all the outdoor scenes in this half of the pilot either take place at night or in the rain - both of which contribute greatly to creating an extremely suitable dark, dank atmosphere. Even when it isn't raining, the ground is often wet.