I cannot vote, because I personally don't think one is better than the other. Contrary to popular opinion, I believe that Barnabas was the death-kiss of the show, but it took four years! Don't get me wrong, I love, absolutely love, the supernatural stuff! But currently viewing the 1897 storyline, there are about four supernatural occurances per episode, and it's a little bit Supernatural Overkill. I think I would enjoy it even more if just half or more of the characters were involved in a "real" storyline, such as infidelity, business takeovers, a murder mystery, catfights in the attic, baby-swapping, alcoholism, paralysis from a carriage accident, etc. It seems to me that it would be enough that they are in another time, period--and maybe have just the Werewolf as part of The supernatural storyline.
But, oh well, this is, I suppose, just the "more is more" approach the show took, beginning with 1795. It's a shame, because with the first Barnabas episodes, and probably the Phoenix episodes, the "less is more" approach worked very, very well. But getting back to why I think Barnabas was the death-kiss, I don't think he would have been if they had kept things like they were in early 1967. I think it was a mistake to make all episodes Barnabas-centric. Once you make one character the focal-point of any television show, once that character or actor leaves the show, you can pretty much guarantee the show will suffer, and/or get cancelled. Can you imagine "Happy Days" without the Fonz? That show never would have lasted if he had left before the end. Anyways, I really believe that Barnabas should have been staked/destroyed. Yes, I loved the 1795 storyline, and think it was a very good idea, but it should have ended with Barnabas begging to be staked, or at least Victoria finding out he was a vampire, and destroying him. The show should have continued to focus solely on the Collins family itself.
I am all for the various supernatural creatures and famous monster movie rip-offs! They should have done a different character every year! But brought in a likable, handsome, melancholy soul like Jonathan Frid or David Selby once a year to play out that particular storyline. And at the end of the year, have them destroyed, leave town, exorcised, or die peacefully. But while all this was going on, they still should have focused on the every day soap opera type stories for the rest of the characters. I believe the show could have gone on for 10, 15, maybe twenty years if they had not focused on Barnabas, and only Barnabas, and the nonstop supernatural events every episode!
But, the show only did last five years, and I will continue to watch it for the outrageous-ness, the campiness, the over-the-top acting and the unbelievable occurances. Not for character development or plausibility!