i beg to differ...the eagle hill caretaker doesn't work for the collins family.he appears to just work at eagle hill cemetery and it's not really made clear who he works for.
remember when eagle hill first appears it's a remote,nearly unused cemetery where ancestors of laura murdcoch(radcliff,stockbridge,collins) were burried.it wasn't the "official" collins cemetery(that ultimately never appears).later it turns up in the barnabas story but again as a remote location not directly run by the collins family.eventually the collins family cemetery stops being mentioned and eagle hill becomes the un-official catch-all for anyone who ever died in collinsport.