1
Current Talk '03 II / More Edits in DS DVD Set 7
« on: October 13, 2003, 10:50:32 PM »
A few weeks ago I posted a message about finding an edit in the DS DVD set 7. Well, now that I have about finished watching that set, I have now found 4 places in those episodes where the material was edited. The places where the edits occurred were in spots where there was damage to the original materal and on the VHS version the screen would momentarily go black. The latest edit I found dealt with a scene where Cassandra and Tony Petersen were in the study talking and it was a two shot with Tony back facing the camera, Cassandra said "look into my eye" and suddenly it jumped to a closeup of Cassandra. It was clear it was an edit. Another edit took place in the scene where Lang was going to use Jeff Clark's head on his creation and Barnabas was debating whether he could go through with it. I remember clearly that scene being damaged in the original VHS version and the screen going black for a moment or two. Again on the DVD the edit is clearly visible because Barnabas is saying one thing and then is saying something totally different a second later.
It is clear now that with this set anyway the technical problems with the episdoes are definitely being edited out. There is no question of it. Once might be a mistake, but several times is someone, on some level, trying to clean up the series. To me that is doing a disservice to the material and the fans alike. If someone is embarrassed by the glitches that exist in the original DS material, I'm sorry, but that goes along with the charm of the show and is a part of the show. Most fans understand and accept that. Sometimes the glitches may be with the picture only and the sound still be there, but by editing that portion out, the sound material is lost as well. To me this is like Joshua Collins rewriting history to suit himself and have history see what he wants it to see. I'm sorry DS is not perfect but that is just part of it and trying to clean it up and take out all the blimishes may make it look better on the surface but is also taking away from the charm of the series, not to mention taking away some material as the edits don't seem to just take away the error but small bits proceeding the error as Midnite found was the case in the first edit I found. This practice be it by Dan Curtis Productions, the place that is putting the show in digital format or MPI needs to stop or the material needs to stop being advertised as complete and unedited because even though entire scenes are not being cut, there are edits in the material which means it is not complete and not unedited.
Richard Holt
It is clear now that with this set anyway the technical problems with the episdoes are definitely being edited out. There is no question of it. Once might be a mistake, but several times is someone, on some level, trying to clean up the series. To me that is doing a disservice to the material and the fans alike. If someone is embarrassed by the glitches that exist in the original DS material, I'm sorry, but that goes along with the charm of the show and is a part of the show. Most fans understand and accept that. Sometimes the glitches may be with the picture only and the sound still be there, but by editing that portion out, the sound material is lost as well. To me this is like Joshua Collins rewriting history to suit himself and have history see what he wants it to see. I'm sorry DS is not perfect but that is just part of it and trying to clean it up and take out all the blimishes may make it look better on the surface but is also taking away from the charm of the series, not to mention taking away some material as the edits don't seem to just take away the error but small bits proceeding the error as Midnite found was the case in the first edit I found. This practice be it by Dan Curtis Productions, the place that is putting the show in digital format or MPI needs to stop or the material needs to stop being advertised as complete and unedited because even though entire scenes are not being cut, there are edits in the material which means it is not complete and not unedited.
Richard Holt