Author Topic: Discuss - house of Dark Shadows  (Read 691 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Watching Project

  • Guest
Discuss - house of Dark Shadows
« on: November 22, 2010, 11:40:43 PM »
We've reached the point in the Watching Project where house of Dark Shadows was starting to open across the country so we're posting this topic for anyone who wishes to discuss hoDS - particularly while the regular WP is on hiatus this Thanksgiving week and the upcoming three week Holidays/New Years break.

If you don't own the official VHS copy, the laserdisc copy, or a recorded from TV copy of hoDS, remember that the movie is available for streaming and/or download on both Amazon Video On Demand and Itunes.  [hall2_smiley]

(And to coincide with this topic captures will be posted to both the "Caption This! - house of Dark Shadows" and "Complete This Phrase / Fill In The Blank(s) - house of Dark Shadows" boards.)

Offline The Doctor and K9

  • Senior Poster
  • ****
  • Posts: 845
  • Karma: +1584/-6282
  • Gender: Male
  • I Love DS!
    • View Profile
Re: Discuss - house of Dark Shadows
« Reply #1 on: November 25, 2010, 02:52:44 PM »
I've watched this movie with many non DS fans, and they always find it confusing. If the audience for the film were comprised of DS fans, the characters would need no introduction. Unfortunately many movie goers were uninitiated to the World of Dark Shadows. The show was on in the daytime. Many people were working. Unlike today, there was no timeshifting or Soap Net. So we open with Maggie. Who is she? We know she's looking for David, but that's it. We know that "he's not in Mrs. Stoddard's room". Who is she? David's mother? Well, we find out soon enough that Mr. Collins is David's father and Maggie is obviously his employee. She goes off looking for him. We are introduced to Elizabeth and Carolyn. If we are paying attention, we might connect that she's Mrs. Stoddard. In my experience with reasonably intelligent people watching the film, the last name goes out into the ether, unremembered the assumption is made that she's Roger's wife. She's a bit old to be David's mother, but not impossibly so. She's pushing 60 and he's about 13; she could have had a child that late in life. She looks more like his grandmother though. If that's the case, where is David's mother? We are never told. If we are paying very close attention, we might work out that Elizabeth Collins Stoddard, as she's eventually identified, MUST be Roger's sister. Carolyn is clearly her daughter, so we know she's his cousin. That's asking a great deal from you audience and would ordinarily earn a charge of "sloppy writing". However, if one reads the script in the Movie Book, most of these questions are answered! They only leave out the whereabouts of David's mother. The gutted theatrical version excises much of the necessary exposition, leaving the character's relationships a jumbled mess for the audience to decipher.