Everyone complains about Maggie in this story, but don't forget, they are basing it on Rebecca. She's supposed to be mousy and timid and actually, given the life she's led, does show more spark than that. And, Quentin is supposed to fly off the handle over any suggestion of anything concerning Angelique. Sometimes in this story it doesn't always seem to make sense, but just picture it as Rebecca.
The 2nd Mrs. DeWinter was shy but brave. Maxim was older, aristocratic, also mysterious and moody, and as the story progressed became increasingly withdrawn. PT Maggie, on the other hand, deals with nearly every situation by running from the room crying. And PT Quentin is a brute who, at one of his lowest points, orders his wife to her room as if doling out a timeout to a child. I find their scenes together very nearly intolerable.
Can't agree with you more, Midnite. If I were Maggie, I would have walked out after the champagne and cold crabmeat incident then would have insisted that Hoffman be sacked before I would come back.
I find Dr. Eric Lang and Gerards comments very intriguing. However,[spoiler]I don't know that it is a given that Barnabas inherits automatically. Jeremiah co-owned the shipyards with his brother Joshua. If Jeremiah had children and they inherited his portion, they may have bought the cash poor widow off. Barnabas' heirs would have had nothing. There is too much left unknown about PT Barnabas[/spoiler]