1. Peter/Jeff was in love with Vicki, no matter which person he was.
Why should Eve accept that reasoning any more than Angelique accepted the "Barnabas is in love with Josette" reasoning?
2. Eve looks NOTHING like Danielle, so why would he instantly fall in love with her again? Why would he even believe her in the first place? Just proving to him that he's really Peter and not Jeff wouldn't make him automatically believe that she's Danielle.
Eve may not look like Danielle, but her soul is the same. And she believes that Peter is her soulmate. As for Jeff believing her....she's working on that.
3. Peter wrote her that letter saying that he was in love with someone else.
Too bad. Peter and Eve are soulmates. They belong together. And so on. Peter just needs to be brought to his senses. She's working on it.
4. He had to know how evil and nasty she was!
She wasn't evil and nasty. She was just pragmatic. Just ask her!
My problem with that storyline is that it just seems so completely unlikely to start with. Peter was a nobody, living in a nothing town, so what would Danielle see in him? That, in fact, was what I liked about the Vicky/Peter story: Peter's a nobody who becomes somebody. But the Eve business just wrecks all that.
PS: Brandon, I hope I didn't come across as overly harsh. I didn't mean to be, but it can happen when I get opinionated.