Sorry about not posting this earlier but it was a real long shot that I even stumbled across it.
The game show channel Buzzr just ran a To Tell The Truth episode from 1958 with Joan Bennett as a panelist. I checked their website and even though they don't post the panelists names on their episode guide, they do put up the original air date when it first aired. Using that as a reference, the episode will be repeated 2am on Sunday morning October 16th. Allow 40 minutes due extra commercials including the original network commercials.
