I am not exactly sure why you want me to look at a comment I left a while back.
Only that you'd seen Darren's comment. No more.
Burton certainly now has mastered the art of 3-D but I am still undecided if the DS movie should be filmed in that format
Like you, I'm undecided as well. And like KMR, I don't see where it would enhance the story - well, beyond a few fright gags. DS is something that should rely more on character than gags - though, if used sparingly, a few good 3D gags certainly wouldn't hurt the story - especially if they're used for surprise effect. And the good thing from the perspective of people who wouldn't like DS in 3D is that, like
Avatar and
Alice in Wonderland, the Depp/DS film would most probably be shown in 2D as well. And the DVD/Blu Ray release, well, at least the first one, would most probably be in 2D because not very many people are likely to run out to buy 3D TVs right away.
Filming the DS movie is now certainly a strong possibility especially if WB and Burton wishes for that format.
I guess now it's my turn to be a bit confused.
Did you mean that you've had real doubts that the movie would be filmed?