Funny, I have the exact opposite reactions to the films. I LOVE NoDS, but hoDS leaves me cold - mostly because it completely sacrifices character development in favor of blood and gore. Not that I dislike blood and gore. Far from it. But it's far more effective when one actually cares about the characters. And who could possibly care much about characters when one knows so little about them? (I mean, in the beginning of the film as it stands now one doesn't even know if Roger and Liz are husband and wife, brother and sister, cousins, or whatever other relationships might be possible.
) Basically the only way to care about them is to transfer ones feelings for their daytime series counterparts. However, the characters in hoDS are not those same people. Not by a long shot...