They're two different games. The first Dark Shadows one has a paper game board and playing cards (the Barnabas wallet photos are the extra in it that seems to be rarely ever found with the game). The Barnabas one has the spinner and the skeletons to build.
Being the collector that I am, I have both games with the two wallet photos and the fangs. I actually just got the Dark Shadows game a couple of weeks ago from a friend. He'd had it packed away for years and it's in excellent condition. The wallet photos don't even have creases. Don't have the viewmaster reels or the puzzles.
Wish I could've seen the easter egg, PennyDreadful, but since I had one of the first copies you sent out, I didn't reply for the new one.