I was able to see roughly the first 30 minutes of the pilot before I had to leave. What I saw I liked and would make a few minor changes. David, Roger, Liz, Vicki, Willie, Kelly and Carolyn can stay. I was unimpressed with Joe and would like to see a guy who looked like he could do a hard days labor but still be attractive to a Carolyn type. In addition to recasting Joe, I would change Barnabas, Dr. Hoffman and Sophie. Vicki supposedly has some background in psychology which seems odd. Despite perhaps being a tad young to be so experienced, she was definitely an asset. She's definitely a keeper. Loved David's character!
The actor playing Dr. Hoffman is totally wrong. I don't know why, but I just don't care for her. I just can't imagine her getting even a itty bitty drop of blood or guts on her immaculate looks and finger nails. Barnabas is too short! Barnabas needs to be imposing and tall. A man who catches your eye and attracts you too him. He needs to be elegant but not too refined because afterall he lived hundres of years ago while American was still finding its way as far as fashion, society, etc. While I don't remember the Sophie character I'd like to suggest that she be a little more conversative and provide balance for the younger characters. I picture her as a salt of the earth type character who is the glue that keeps the house running while Roger and Liz deal with each other and the rest of the family and acquaintances. I see her as an employee who knows a lot about what's going on and can handle it.